I called him "capable" as a non-Padre. I think that's a pretty fair adjective. Now, as for your argument. You cherry pick his career high from 5 years ago for SO/9, but his career rate is 8.9 and this year is 8.3. That's hardly a major difference. His career walk rate is 3.6 BB/9 and this year is 3.3. His velocity charts don't indicate any significant trend. And, yes, his BABIP is very low and indicates he may see a regression, but even a regression from him easily makes him our second best reliever. I'm not going to continue this because if you cherry pick anyone's career year and compare it to a particular season you could argue he's "declining". It's a really unfair way to make your argument.