No, its not a good offer. You'd be lucky to get a polite "no" when you would deserve to be hung up on. Youre trying to have your cake and eat it too: yes, Archer is a far better player. But that comes at a far higher cost. You dont want Cole cost for Cole performance, but You want to pay Cole-cost (maybe, not even sure of that) for Archer performance. Sorry, thats just not reaslistic.