I don't quite understand how Tonkin can be considered, especially since he had spent so much time in the show. He certainly has as many, and without looking it up, I would say more innings in the majors than Hildenberger. So I am not saying either shouldn't be considered, but I don't understand what disqualifies someone from your award. Busenitz has been wonderful in his appearances in the show, Curtiss pretty awful (and I see that two of the voters didn't even have him in their top 5, and Cody Christie didn't have Curtiss or Anderson in his top 5), and Wimmers, Rucinski, and Turley, also saw time up, but were still in the mix. What was the line drawn that made someone ineligible? And congrats to your winner, Curtiss.