Ron Davis had 14 blown saves and 11 losses in 1984, including two blown saves in the last week of the season, and the Twins finished 3 games short of the division crown. Granted, they were not likely to get past Detroit in the playoffs. Billy Gardner was the manager in '84, and he did not know how to use his bullpen. Davis was often called up to close the game in the 8th, even when he was not playing well. '84 isn't 100% on Davis, but 50% is bad enough. Davis put up worse numbers in 1986, though he was not "the closer" for long. He had a high profile meltdown very early in the season during a television interview, where he fought back tears while saying he had never pitched worse in his life, and from then on he did not appear in high-leverage situations. By the time Tom Kelly took over the team near the end of '86, Davis had been traded. Davis was under a lot of pressure as he was always expected by the media to be elite. By all accounts, he was a good guy who had too much on his shoulders. He did not perform well in high pressure situations, and the Twins managers of the era (Gardner and Mauch) were just not good at reading that sort of thing. If Gardenhire had kept Hawkins as the closer for five years longer than he did, the results would have been similar. The Twins got a lot of prospects when they traded Davis, which shows that people thought he could pitch in spite of his results. Reardon came on in '87. He struggled most of the year, but down the stretch he was suddenly able to throw Blyleven's magical curveball, and the rest his history. Reardon's performance did not come back down to earth for another five years.