Gardy made it sound like there could be no reasonable case made for not bunting in that situation. I think that's a large part of the heat he's taking on this. The guy's batting .310 or something and he's been red hot... asking him to bunt almost completely eliminates the possibility that he could hit a double or even a triple, driving in one or two and putting another runner in scoring position. Gardy's big into lefty/righty splits, I understand, but he really should have looked more closely at Rzepcyznski's numbers against right-handed hitters (spoiler alert, they're terrible). Santana was in a great position to make a big inning out of it. It's been my opinion that 95% of all situations that call for a sac bunt occur in National League parks. I could get in to the probability of scoring runs via swinging vs. bunting, but other people have done that quite extensively. In this one situation, Gardy made the wrong choice, and what's worse he made it sound like he'd make that wrong choice 100% of the time.