Let's try to quantify how Mauer was coddled in 2014. Mauer was on the DL from early July to early August with the oblique injury. Outside of that, he missed the following games while active: May 5th May 6th May 7th May 8th May 9th June 8th Aug. 28th (entered as PH in the 10th inning) Sept. 22nd Sept. 24th I'm not recalling what the issue in May was that he sat out five straight. I was a bit bothered by Gardenhire sitting him out while healthy on Sept. 22nd and 24th, saying something about he wanted to get Vargas in a first during the Diamondbacks series and put him back in for the final series in Detroit when the games mattered. That D'backs series was at home. Mauer DHed 19 times. Seven of those games were after Vargas was called up on Aug. 1, so I'll give them a bit of a pass on the assumption that they were trying to gauge Vargas's fielding. In the 12 games Mauer DHed before Aug. 1, two came on days when there was a double-header, Apr. 17 and May 1, and he played first base in the other game that day. I'll be on record that playing first base twice in a double-header situation doesn't seem all that daunting compared to most other positions. So was he coddled? I do think that the Twins had him DH a little too much, considering he's no longer primarily a catcher and they had some other options who were probably best suited to DH on those days. They might have been a little too cautious with the oblique injury, considering he missed about a month, but who knows.