I would have gone with May, personally. I get that there was a lot of game left, and someone was going to need to soak up innings, but there was still plenty of time to bring in Achter. Once it was clear that Trout would hit in the 2nd, I would have had someone else warming up to pitch to him. Someone who is one of the best eight relievers on the team. Molitor is more avant-garde than Gardenhire was, but he's proving that he's still a very old-school manager.