#6. Even you state he is not ready.
#5 Speed is barely used by the Twins now. Buxton and Gordon both have it and it doesn’t seem to be utilized. This regime values homers. And this guy hasn’t really hit that well at AA
#4 and #3 Don’t know a lot about these two, can they field the position? IMO that is important. Can they handle a part time position? They did have nice seasons, but not sure they would be much of an improvement.
#2 if he isn’t playing every day, I would prefer he starts next year at SP
#1 I do like his versatility, has pretty much quit hitting though. And he bats right handed.
I am not even that big of a fan of Cave, but he did hit right handers pretty good a couple of seasons back, and was playing hurt much of this season.
Wondering why you didn’t mention Larnach, Martin, Rooker or Garlick