Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    Are the Twins Finally Buckling Under the Weight of Their Challenges?


    Nick Nelson

    It's quite amazing that the Twins have done as well as they have, given all they've been dealt. But as we reach the final stretch of the season, there are signs that the weight of it all is becoming too much to bear.

    Image courtesy of John Hefti-USA TODAY Sports

    Twins Video

    I am beyond impressed by what the Minnesota Twins have done up to this point. It's a team that makes me feel proud to root for them. This group has shown incredible determination and resiliency to put themselves in the position they are currently in: less than three games out of first place, squarely in playoff position, with 30 games left in the season. They are outpacing their preseason over/under and on pace for nearly 90 wins, a mark they've reached once in the past 13 years.

    They have managed to do this DESPITE all of the following:

    • Ownership slashing payroll during the offseason and giving the front office no flexibility to replace outgoing talent, much less add on.
    • Stumbling to a 7-13 start that left them eight games out of first place by April 21st.
    • The bullpen gradually whittling down to two or three trustworthy options -- in part because the front office's lone deadline acquisition was a total failure, released within one month of being acquired.
    • Suddenly losing Joe Ryan, a borderline All-Star and (still) their staff leader in fWAR, for the season in early August. 
    • Lengthy injuries for Byron Buxton and Royce Lewis, as well as -- most critically -- the loss of a borderline MVP contender in Carlos Correa, the heart and soul of their team, for six weeks running.

    Through all of this, the Twins have battled and endured. For a while, they were hanging in there, consistently winning and splitting series to make up ground on Cleveland and close the gap in the AL Central. Even without Correa, or Buxton or Ryan for the most part, they won 11 of their first 16 games in August, shaving 4 ½ games off the division lead. 

    But eventually, all of these setbacks and limitations are going to collectively catch up with you, and it feels like we're seeing that play out in real-time with the Twins. They've proven they are a great team when their horses are mostly healthy and performing, but with so many of their top players down, it goes without saying this squad is only a severely diminished version of its best self. The remaining players who are left to carry the load seem to be wearing down and buckling under all the weight they've been left to bear.

    This feels palpably apparent in Minnesota's recent results, with crushing defeat after crushing defeat. The Twins have dropped seven of their past nine, and they've given up leads at the end of the game in four of those. Increasingly the club's performance is characterized by sloppiness, rapid meltdowns on the mound, and blown opportunities at the plate. 

    It's not just missing three key players that hurts, it's the nature of those losses: a starting pitcher, starting shortstop and starting center fielder are perhaps the three most difficult positions to backfill, especially when those players are arguably three of the five best on the team. These are devastating injuries and the Twins have been left reeling, with young players pushed aggressively into roles they probably aren't ready for out of necessity. Under different circumstances, Edouard Julien and Austin Martin would likely not be in the majors, much less costing the Twins crucial games with their bats and gloves. 

    The most troubling part is that there's no real light at the end of the tunnel.

    Ryan won't be back. Correa might not be. And it's unclear when Buxton will be able to return or how effective he'll be. There are some potential longshot reinforcements to bolster the bullpen internally but the unit is in rough shape. Meanwhile, one more significant injury in the rotation, bullpen or lineup could snap this sinking ship in half like the Titanic.

    Even if things don't manage to get worse, the tough reality is that it's difficult to envision a major change for the better in the circumstances the Twins face. Therefore, the guys who are still here and grinding away -- as well as Brooks Lee, one of the few key reinforcements whose return does feel imminent -- need to find it within themselves to rekindle their spark and rise above it all in the final month of the season. 

    If they can't, this beleaguered squad appears destined for a quick playoff exit or even missing out on the postseason entirely; a legitimately excellent team crushed by the burden of endless second-half setbacks.

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    I have been down on this team all year.  I have said time and time again that their record was mainly due to them beating up on the 5 worst teams in the league and playing sub-.500 against everyone else.  This team has been smoke-and-mirrors all year.

    That being said:

    You can question Rocco all you want, but with every bad thing thrown at the Twins this year, if they make the playoffs, you can easily make the argument that he is the AL Manager of the Year.  

    I have tickets to the Twins/Red Sox games next month. It is feasible that this could determine the last playoff spot. My fingers are crossed that the Twins will lock up a spot during the KC/Clev. games.

    The Fenway visitor's bullpen has to be the most challenging location in the game. The bleacher fans harass the pitchers during warm up.

    10 hours ago, Major League Ready said:

    KC and the Twins followed used some similar tactics.  The Twins spent their FA / extension money on Correa / Buston and Lopez.  The Royals spent their money on Perez / Lugo and Wacha.  Perez is playing great while Buxton and Correa are on the IL.  Lugo has been better the Lopez.  Wacha has been about the same.  Both teams landed an important part of their rotation by trading away players at the deadline.  

    If we look at KC, I would conclude they have gotten more out of modest priced free agents.  They have stayed healthy, and they got one hell of a gift when they traded a rental for Reagans.  BTW … Lugo and Wacha were not at the top of the list here at TD.

    Cleveland is getting absolutely zero contributions for free agents or proven players acquired by trade.  37% of their WAR is from drafted players.  22% from International drafted players.  41% from players acquired as prospects and they don’t have any free agents.  So, how does one look at Cleveland and their 107M payroll and a roster with no free agents and conclude the reason the Guardians are ahead in the standings is the Twins cut spending?

    One huge item, from my perspective, that you do not touch on is that KC has a true superstar as does Cleveland. No Twins is even close to as good as either of those players. 

    All of the teams do their best to put a competitive team on the field and money cannot be an excuse in the AL Central.

    Still expect the Twins to win due to better depth but Correa, Buxton, and Lewis need to play and be effective. I have no illusions of any of them being in a conversation with Ramirez or Junior but the team needs them to play.

    10 hours ago, tony&rodney said:

    One huge item, from my perspective, that you do not touch on is that KC has a true superstar as does Cleveland. No Twins is even close to as good as either of those players. 

    All of the teams do their best to put a competitive team on the field and money cannot be an excuse in the AL Central.

    Still expect the Twins to win due to better depth but Correa, Buxton, and Lewis need to play and be effective. I have no illusions of any of them being in a conversation with Ramirez or Junior but the team needs them to play.

    Very true but I was addressing the very firmly held assumption by some that the reason the Twins won’t catch Cleveland is because of spending.  Cleveland is spending less and KC the same so that position is misguided.  

    Why isn’t anyone asking how these teams were constructed?  Did KC and Cleveland sign their superstars as free agents.  Did they trade prospects for them?  They drafted and extended them.  That said, the Angels (Traut and Ohtani)  are proof that having a superstar or even two is of no value without a team around them.  

    What we should be asking is how successful teams with similar or less revenue accumulated enough talent to be legit contenders.  What percentage of their high contributing players were drafted or acquired as prospects vs free agency or trading for established players?   There is not one person among those insisting the answer is spending that has shown these acquisition methods are prominent strategies among teams in the bottom half of revenue.  The first clue should be that Cleveland does not have a single free agent contributing to their team nor do they have a player that was acquired as an established player.  
     

    11 hours ago, tony&rodney said:

    One huge item, from my perspective, that you do not touch on is that KC has a true superstar as does Cleveland. No Twins is even close to as good as either of those players. 

    All of the teams do their best to put a competitive team on the field and money cannot be an excuse in the AL Central.

    Still expect the Twins to win due to better depth but Correa, Buxton, and Lewis need to play and be effective. I have no illusions of any of them being in a conversation with Ramirez or Junior but the team needs them to play.

    I'm not really arguing your point... perhaps just muddying it up a little. 

    I'd say Royce Lewis belongs in that superstar. Health hasn't cooperated and in my opinion... health is the thing that has kept him out of that group... but I believe he belongs in that group. I'm not saying who I think is better amongst those three... I'm saying Royce belongs in that conversation. Health is why he isn't but if on the field... I got him in the conversation.  

    You point out the health issue on the superstar level. Our biggest issue is that Willi Castro, Carlos Santana and Max Kepler lead the team in AB's. They have been average players to slightly above average players. The stats they are producing isn't lead the team in AB stats. In Cleveland and Kansas City... Ramirez and Witt lead the team in AB's. 

    The Twins have done a decent job covering for our significant losses with a better lineup 1 through 10 as you point out. You'll notice the 1 through 10 (not 13) as I'm tossing Margot, Farmer and Vazquez overboard. 😉

    As a team, the one offensive thing that Kansas City is doing better than Minnesota is hitting with runners in scoring position. Kansas City leads baseball with a .294 BA with runners in scoring position... 2nd in MLB with a .831 OPS. The Twins are hitting .245 with runners in scoring position good for 21st. 18th with .741 OPS. 

    Kansas City is 30th in K's with runners in scoring position (Therefore Best). Cleveland is 28th. Twins are 13th which is better than last year but... we haven't been as clutch despite what I believe a deeper team.   

     

    1 hour ago, Riverbrian said:

    I'd say Royce Lewis belongs in that superstar. Health hasn't cooperated and in my opinion... health is the thing that has kept him out of that group... but I believe he belongs in that group. I'm not saying who I think is better amongst those three... I'm saying Royce belongs in that conversation. Health is why he isn't but if on the field... I got him in the conversation.

    495 vs 1922 is the career comparison for PA (RL-JR.). I love watching Royce Lewis but he can never reach the status of an Aaron Judge, Juan Soto, Shohei Ohtani, or Bobby Witt Jr. Lewis is a year older than Junior and cannot do anything as well as the KC shortstop. Superstar is a separate category earned through consistent production year over year. Star potential is an entirely different matter, where young inexperienced players with talent or prospects are discussed. Lewis is still in that category. I often mention that it is somewhat unfair to compare emerging players to the real stars. We would like Royce to settle into being a productive player whose name is in the lineup every day, hopefully playing in the field as opposed to being a 25 year old DH. We know injuries happen (Buxton, Correa) and can see that even the best (Trout) can have their run of excellence thwarted by injuries. Lewis has never been in the conversation as a top player in baseball. He did garner huge love with his grand slams last season and two home runs in the playoffs. Royce can be good and still has potential. I need to see a minimum of 500 PA in several consecutive seasons (which still falls well short of what we see from Junior, Shohei, and Soto every year) before I consider any reason to put Lewis in a higher category than MLB player. I just hope the pressure of  expectations are not a hindrance to Lewis but Royce has a good head and that doesn't seem like it should be a problem for him. 

    2 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

    495 vs 1922 is the career comparison for PA (RL-JR.). I love watching Royce Lewis but he can never reach the status of an Aaron Judge, Juan Soto, Shohei Ohtani, or Bobby Witt Jr. Lewis is a year older than Junior and cannot do anything as well as the KC shortstop. Superstar is a separate category earned through consistent production year over year. Star potential is an entirely different matter, where young inexperienced players with talent or prospects are discussed. Lewis is still in that category. I often mention that it is somewhat unfair to compare emerging players to the real stars. We would like Royce to settle into being a productive player whose name is in the lineup every day, hopefully playing in the field as opposed to being a 25 year old DH. We know injuries happen (Buxton, Correa) and can see that even the best (Trout) can have their run of excellence thwarted by injuries. Lewis has never been in the conversation as a top player in baseball. He did garner huge love with his grand slams last season and two home runs in the playoffs. Royce can be good and still has potential. I need to see a minimum of 500 PA in several consecutive seasons (which still falls well short of what we see from Junior, Shohei, and Soto every year) before I consider any reason to put Lewis in a higher category than MLB player. I just hope the pressure of  expectations are not a hindrance to Lewis but Royce has a good head and that doesn't seem like it should be a problem for him. 

    Not really arguing what you are saying. I do understand what you are saying. 

    I have no way of proving what I think because Royce has been horrible at the health thing and he would ultimately be my proof if healthy... which he consistently hasn't been so all I got his what I think.  

    I Just believe in my heart... that Royce when ON THE FIELD and in the lineup. Belongs in the conversation. 

    But, I understand the importance of increasing his sample to a punctuation mark on my what I think.  

    This is just who they are.

    It’s not surprising that Buxton, Correa, and Ryan couldn’t put together a full season.  That’s a given.

    They’ve been bolstered by unsustainable performances for much longer than they should’ve been.

    Royce Lewis wasn’t going to continue to hit .300 with a home run rate equivalent to Judge.

    Miranda wasn’t going to continue to hit .350.

    Ober wasn’t going to continue to pitch at a Cy Young level.

    Vasquez wasn’t going to continue to win you games with clutch hits.

    Willie Castro wasn’t going to continue to produce like an All Star offensively.

    The bullpen was a powder keg waiting to blow from day 1.

    Theyre extremely fortunate to be where they are, given the roster construction.  It’s just not that good of a team, and it’s finally caught up with them as it should have a long time ago.

    1 hour ago, Beast said:

    This is just who they are.

    It’s not surprising that Buxton, Correa, and Ryan couldn’t put together a full season.  That’s a given.

    They’ve been bolstered by unsustainable performances for much longer than they should’ve been.

    Royce Lewis wasn’t going to continue to hit .300 with a home run rate equivalent to Judge.

    Miranda wasn’t going to continue to hit .350.

    Ober wasn’t going to continue to pitch at a Cy Young level.

    Vasquez wasn’t going to continue to win you games with clutch hits.

    Willie Castro wasn’t going to continue to produce like an All Star offensively.

    The bullpen was a powder keg waiting to blow from day 1.

    Theyre extremely fortunate to be where they are, given the roster construction.  It’s just not that good of a team, and it’s finally caught up with them as it should have a long time ago.

    And yet, with all the above, the Twins are still a fair bet to be in the playoffs and even win the division. The Twins are not done. I'm not wishing for bad luck and knocking on wood.




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...