Agree, that Baldelli isn't really using analytics. His decisions may be from a data set, but that data set clearly doesn't ever update and it clearly isn't a deep dive into individual at bats, matchups or situations.
Young lefties bat X against left handed pitchers. Pinch runners are X amount more likely to score than the better hitter they are replacing. Young pitchers perform X against hitters the third time through the order. Manny Margot is a capable pinch hitter.
If he's managing via computer these are all surface level evaluations and they are clearly not accounting for current data (if it did, it would say Manny Margot should never pinch hit some time around June). And he's clearly not analyzing if maybe Matt Wallner SHOULD stay in and hit with X amount of outs, against this particular pitcher, in this particular inning, in this particular stadium, in this particular month, etc, etc.