I'm actually wondering if the A's do that deal. Lewis hasn't played in two years and SWR has consistency issues, and Urshela is coming off a down year - which could get worse moving from the very hitter friendly Yankee stadium to the polar opposite Oakland Coliseum.
That said, just because SS would be filled by Story, assuming Lewis is surplus just because of that seems foolhardy if you believe that he can play SS. An athlete like that can play anywhere - including CF. I'm one that feels Lewis is pretty important to this team. If he pans out, that's a game changer along with Martin and Buxton. Which is why, in this scenario, I'd say no. I don't think it moves the needle enough to counter the loss of Lewis and SWR for a longer run than 2024. I also believe that this team has internal options to fill in at 3B, including Lewis and/or Martin.
I'd be more interested in going after Manaea on his own, but that's a much different trade scenario.