All I can say is that the ASG was fun to be at last year. The Home Run derby was probably more fun, but that also had a lot to do with the copious amounts of beer that was consumed before/during the event. The rain delay helped with that. As far as this goes, I don't think most of those players deserve to be at the ASG, if the rosters were actually constructed on who are the best players at the position. But, it is also based on fan participation, so if you don't like it, start voting.