I thought saying the pledge in schools was something schools couldn’t require, based on a case where someone refused and was expelled? Didn’t it go to the SC, and now schools cannot require it? Don’t recall the details, but I think it involved a school somewhere in Texas, of course. If I were a teacher, I would also use the pledge as a teaching opportunity, as ewen has said he does. Depending on the grade and ages of students, I would discuss its origins, the author, how it has changed through the years and why, its meaning and definitions of the words. (As a 5 yr old, I could barely pronounce everything, let alone understand individual meanings of the words, let alone understand why we did this). So often with these various traditions we have surrounding the symbols of our country, it has become recitation without understanding or meaning or feeling. I think it’s important that students have genuine understanding, and then, as adults, can make choices of patriotism that have true meaning to them, and not simply to do it because that’s just how and what is done. And be respectful of everyone’s choices in the matter. We said the pledge and sang ‘My Country ‘Tis of Thee’ every morning when I was in grade school, with our hands over our hearts. It was just what we learned to do and did. It was a little ... robotic and indoctrinating ... for lack of a better description, as it was simply ‘Do this because this is what we do and you’ll get in trouble if you don’t.’