Jorgenswest wasn't on the final list of three. I wouldn't have approved him/her as a moderator for the reasons you stated ... and I find him even more rigid than the others you mentioned. I initially hesitated about Hosken, then relented, and now I'm hesitant again, but, I'm going to go with it. I do think he's thoughtful and intelligent, but, I can't exactly put my finger on it, there's just something that doesn't quite sit well with me. But I go back and forth. it's done now, anyway, if Brock has actually PM'd him. We'll find out as soon as Brock is back from vacation.