He was? Based on what? I'd say Santana was. Anyway in Gibson's last three starts, he had one quality start, gave up 11 ER in only 16 2/3 IP to include his last start where he gave up 3 ER, threw 87 pitches, and didn't make it out of the 4th. And in 3 of the 11 starts he had in the last 2 months, he didn't make it out of the 5th three times. This is the guy you think should have started our playoff game (not a game 163)? Yeah, no.