Yeah, I'm not missing any point. You want to say he'll be great defensively right away and what is this based on? Fielding %? Additionally, Russell was a much higher prospect than Gordon and much better offensively in A+ ball than Gordon (with though Russell had a worse BABIP) and yet Russell has still only managed to be around average offensively in the majors and he isn't great himself. Correa, Lindor, Seager, Bogaerts, Crawford. THEY are great shortstops. Russell is above average who could be great one day. His bat, so far, prevents him from being great. If Gordon comes in and plays great defense and has a 60 wRC+, he won't be GREAT. He'll be ok. Buxton, for example, played great defense, but he's not great yet (though, September looked promising) Expecting Gordon to be great right away sets him up for disappointment, like the expectations put on Buxton. If he comes up and is just ok his first year, that will work. Greatness will, perhaps, come later.