If Eddie is a tick above replacement level, then we need to collectively rethink what constitutes replacement level. Rosario's offense is basically major league average right now (major league OPS is .761, LF are slightly higher at .781, and for fun CFs are sitting at .765, with Rosario sitting at .767). Offensively, he's slightly better than average while being slightly below average among LF. Defensively, Rosario is above average, and I think we all agree there. That is not a replacement level player. Even if the mythical replacement level player existed, you won't get that kind of production out of said player. Rosario is a player that can be upgraded, but in general, that's a player that helps you more than he hurts you. As I stated before, Rosario's peripherals are trending in the right direction. Given his age, present contributions, and above average defense, he's going to be around while that trend continues, and he should be. Rosario is not the problem on this team right now.