DocBauer

If you believe in FIELDING % as a stat, Kirilloff is just fine at 1B. If you watch a lot of games in which he plays, the eye will tell you he's not smooth, but he's OK there. He can be better. And I have to wonder if he's sound physically and the bat is working, does he relax a bit and just focus more on his defense to take it up a notch? I mean, he's been dealing with a lot the past 3 years with injuries, surgeries, batting numbers, the fate of his career, etc. Not going to make excuses for a professional not improving as much as we'd like in some aspect of their game, just wondering if less pressure would lead to more confidence. As for his bat? MOSTLY healthy for about 4 months he produced AVG, OB%, and power to the tune of an OPS PLUS of 117. I think he can do that again, and probably even a little better, as long as his wrist issues are behind him...they appear to be...and he doesn't severely damage some other part of his body. (minor injuries will always happen). I'm not a big fan of the Santana signing, with all due respect to his career. He's been pretty bad since 2019. He found a resurgence in 2023 that I have a hard time believing he will be able to duplicate in 2024 at age 38. And he's been mediocre to poor from the left side against RHP for even longer now. And that's a pretty big issue considering about 75% of all pitchers throw from the right side. Still, I don't hate the move. His bat from the RH side appears to still have some juice left. He's still at least a solid defender. There's definitely room for him in his role as a player and leader/professional example. But long term, 1B is going to need to be addressed at some point in 2025. And if AK's healthy, I believe his bat plays. PERIOD. But the Twins don't want a full time DH. They want a deep enough lineup where the DH spot is used to rotate different bats due to depth, and half days off for guys. So it's still paramount that Kirilloff continues to play and work at 1B. I still have some belief that Miranda's issue last year was his shoulder. Now that he's healthy again, there's an opportunity to regain his status as "part of the future of the club" as a 1B/DH/PH and possibly a sometime 3B. But he's going to almost assuredly begin 2024 with St Paul. And that's fine. He'll be up with the Twins at some point as long as he's healthy and producing. Long story short, a healthy Kirilloff has a quality ML bat that, potentially, might be well above average. With health, IMO, comes production that you make room for. But some of that "room" should be at 1B against RHP for the best lineup today, as well as preparing for the future. Just handing him a glove on day and telling him to go play isn't preparing him for either time line.

I'm a little higher on Cory Lewis from the 2022 draft, one pick after Matthews, but only a little. Guess a few more K's and a little more reported velocity gives him a leg up to me. But I'm not sure I'd call Matthews as under the radar. He and Lewis and Culpepper all seem to get a fair amount of love. There's other arms, including some from the same draft, that are talked about less. (In general, I know we're talking about this particular game). The numbers De Andrade put up as a 19yo were pretty awesome. He looks to have some nice upside as a hitter. He'd be a solid, young prospect at 3B, or even 2B, but he's that much more "important" as a prospect if he can stick at SS and not grow out of it physically. But not even 20yo for about 20 more days, he's got plenty of time to develop. Really impressed with the development of Rosario last season. Its my understanding he's not fleet of foot, and is rather average, but with a pretty decent arm. He's going to be all about the bat as what you're looking for is average defense at a corner spot. And that would be enough if the bat plays as potentially projected. I think arms like Crisostomo, Juan Mendez, and Miguel Rodriguez are more under the radar.

I have a dream. NOT the dream where Kate Beckinsale loves my eyes and my smile, but a dream where MLB wakes up and adopts various principles of the NFL and the NBA. MLB suddenly adopts a FLOOR AND a CAP for equitably profit sharing like the NFL does, WHILE each franchise can STILL collect $M of dollars on their own from merchandising and the such. STUD players get what they deserve, but lower level teams can't keep pocketing MLB welfare money. And if MLB wants to adopt some NBA ideas, they could allow things such as the mid exception cap to allow teams to add a player every year that might put them over the top. The STARS get paid. There's even room for some of the mid guys to get paid. And while the payroll and profit platform isn't perfect, it's at least more equitable than it is now. I remain STUNNED that MLB owners are utterly deaf to seeing what the NFL IS, and what the NBA is KINDA, while they twiddle their thumbs and say "oh my". They're NOT going to have a choice other than WAKE UP over the next few years. Wouldn't it be nice if the Pohlad's, reportedly well respected, took a lead?

Headrick is one of those arms that slips through the cracks. He was drafted in the 9th round in 2019 from a smaller school, which is the FO MO with size or something inherently good to work with. He threw 3.2 innings after signing just to throw. Like many others, he missed all of 2020. In 2021 he threw at Ft Myers ,which was A+ at the time. He did OK. He pretty much torched in the new HIGH A Cedar Rapids for half of 2022, and then was pretty good in AA Wichita. His stuff and improvement, and potential, made the Twins place him on the 40 man to begin 2023. He had a good ST in SSS. He was eradicate when called up. Some good, some bad. Both at AAA and with the Twins. He's not young. He basically didn't pitch for 2yrs...like so many...until 2021. He's actually been moved pretty quickly due to age and potential. He was a surprise 40 man addition following 2022. I don't know that his pure STUFF plays as a ML starting pitcher option. But had he been allowed to just throw on a normal routine for the Saints in 2023 instead of bouncing back and forth between AAA and the Twins in 2023, we might be looking at him differently today. Despite age, he's been rushed somewhat. Being rushed is not always a bad thing. It might be the FO believes in you. But being rushed can also mean a re-set to get your game together. Personally, from what I've seen, Hendricks has some solid stuff, but it's unrefined. He'll get his shot in 2024. But I think he's Thielbar 2.0. And that's not a bad thing

This seems about right to me with roughly 2 weeks left in ST. The Saints need these next couple of weeks for the team to gel and work together. Instead of getting a couple AB in a ML game, guys like Martin and Severino will play more and ramp up. Camargo gets to do the same, but also work more closely with the arms he's going to catch. The Twins still have 3 non roster catchers to work with the arms in camp. In regard to Martin, this is good for him. He gets to play more of a full game and work on driving the ball. It's NOT about power, just barreling up more to drive the ball for singles, doubles, and a few HR. He took a real upturn in his projectible status in the AFL and his limited AAA time. But he can't just "walk" his way in to a ML job. Camargo has improved his bat SO MUCH in the last 2yrs. Now comes just learning a bit more contact, a few less K's, a few more BB, and just keep focusing on defense and game calling. He's got a chance for a solid career. i ignore a kid like Severino having bad numbers in SSSS for his 1st ML ST. NOBODY expected him to rake at this point. He was there as part of the 40 man for experience, coaching, and experience. I have some doubts about his future, but I'm also intrigued by his potential. He has generally even splits as a powerful switch hitter. That alone makes him interesting. Hell, from the day he first signed with Atlanta his entire story is interesting! But he's going to be at AAA at 24yo. I fully expect him to continue to K at 30%. And I fully recognize there is a major difference of milb numbers vs actually being at the ML level! But when a prospect, even a powerful high K prospect can maintain an OB% that is 80 points higher than his batting AVG, I pause for a moment. It makes me think he might have AT LEAST a semi decent BA and continued decent OB% to go along with his power. He wasn't great in 1/4 of a season with the Saints to close 2023, but he wasn't bad either. He still had a .832 OPS. Not bad for an introduction. Barring trades, I'm seeing him and Miranda as part of 2025 and one gone.

I feel like almost everything here about Ryan could apply almost directly to Varland and his new 2 seam sinker. The one game of Varland's against the Pirates, his new sinker looked pretty good to me. I can absolutely see a sinker working in Ryan's favor, even if his K numbers and percentage go down somewhat. While strikeouts are great to have, outs are the most important thing. A few less K's, and a few more easy ground outs and double plays are not only just as effective getting those outs, but it might even shave a few throws off of his IP, allowing to go just a little bit deeper in to games. I'm no expert on pitches themselves, or recognition of them at times. But I'd be really interested in a breakdown of his slider success pre groin injury and post. While not an elite pitch, I thought his slider worked pretty well the first 3-4 months before he was pitching hurt, and then rehabbed but not as affective. Now maybe what I was seeing was the sweeper and/or splitter and not the slider. But I could have sworn I saw a pretty decent slider the 1st half of the season. But even if I'm mistaken, I can still see an average slider working well 15-20% of the time against LH batters.

I think expansion may happen. I hope to the baseball gods it DOESN’T happen! The leagues and divisions are perfectly balanced right now as is. The league is a complete cluster of a mess financially right now! Some teams, Yankees for instance, have their own unique TV deals in place for the near future, at least, and from that and pure population base, have and will always have a financial advantage. Meanwhile, there's more than the 8 teams listed in this OP that have cut, or going to cut, may cut deeper, or have virtually ZERO clue any sort of pending 2025 and beyond broadcasting deals. Some teams have barely been solvent the past few seasons like the A's and Ray's. One has done well and might do better with a new stadium...still a few years away...and the other is such a mess they can't even make the HOPEFUL move to Las Vegas anything other than a messy dream. And some kind of "buy in" deal to MLB for an expansion of teams is a limited reward. Someone please tell me what cities are left that would be viable, profitable options???

Absolutely not an apologist for thr Twins owners, even though I feel that, generally speaking, they do a good job with the organization, and within baseball, and within the community. I hate not spending every penny you can to put the best team on the field every season. I'm really not happy payroll has been cut this season after reaching the playoffs, and having a team primed to do so again. But what this OP announces and details us it isn't just a Twins issue, despite the fact this is about the 12th article about payroll in one form or another since the season ended. The Padres spent way more than they should have, had a huge TV deal, and lost it. Payroll gets cut by 37.5% because not only did they reportedly overspend, but they lost their big TV deal. Thr Angels, who are in LOS ANGELES, cut payroll by 24.4%. I know they're run poorly, but you have to cut payroll in LA?? The Rangers, in a much bigger market than the Twins, and with a TV deal more than double that of the Twins, flush with playoff money, still cut their payroll by 12.4%. What happens to the Rangers next offseason when they aren't getting their approximately $85M that they are receiving for 2024? Is there really a cable or streaming package that's going to rescue them and toss them a $85M life preserver? Without having anything other than educated guesses available to us...with a couple exceptions...we just don't really know how much the Twins, or any team, actually takes in for yearly income. But we do have reports of what some of the TV packages that have expired, been dropped, or are on their last year are worth. And it's not small amounts. That's why you're seeing teams, even teams in larger markets, dropping payroll. And since none of these teams know what's going to happen in 2025 at this point, more cuts are probably coming for some of them. Now, some teams have different deals with different broadcasters that pay well and aren't disappearing. That stinks for the health of the game. And it's about time MLB gets their s**t together and figure out how to make something work with better balance. And that includes getting rid of blackouts and looking to expand internationally. I guess nobody could be blamed for believing so many ownership groups just got cheap and are cutting payroll now because the team income dropped. But do we really believe billionaires across baseball, in all different sizes of markets, are worried about trying to recoup a few more $M? Or is it actually possible that these teams are actually cutting payroll because the loss of the TV revenue actually has them in the red or potentially facing it? I'm just worried how big of a mess it's going to be for the next few years. MLB often adapts and progresses at a drunken snails pace.

Just to add, when Prielipp first had his 2nd surgery, it was reported as TJ surgery. Then it was reported he didn't have another tear...maybe a sprain??...and the brace was put in place. So I think you're right that the whole procedure is a bit of a mystery as to what happened, what they saw, and the recovery plan. It doesn't appear to have been an actual TJ surgery, but more of an additional procedure to add greater stability? If true, we shouldn't be looking at a 14 month rehab. But I have a hard time seeing 6 months either. But it would seem mid season to begin to rehab and throw normally. If he could be cutting loose about July, even on limited innings, that should put him on course for a normal 2025. That could mean an escalation through A ball and a finish at AA. And that could mean a debut, potentially, in 2026?

I'd definitely like to see Canterino at St Paul for sure. I'm just looking at DeScalfini feeling good and projecting as of NOW to be ready when they need him. So I'm just speculating there might be a crunch for the first month. Hard to find anyone as high on Canterino than me! :) I'm confused about Ohl. I think there is NO SP flying under the radar in the entire system more than him! Despite great control and a collection of solid secondary offerings, a really good 2023, and reportedly throwing mid 90's consistently these days, why didn't he get an invite to ST? Are they trying to "hide" him a little from other teams? Doesn't make sense to me because if he's what I think he might be, he could see ML time in 2025. I'm higher on Dobank than you and others are. Hes not a prospect, and hes not part of the Twins future. But with his experience, if his hand is finally 100%, I could see him doing great at St Paul this year and be a viable call up June/July if injuries hit and the Twins don't want to turn to a younger Festa or Canterino at that point. I think Ohl MIGHT start at AA just becasue of Varland, SWR, Festa, Hendrick, Canterino potentially at AAA. But yeah, I'd like him at AAA too. I generally agree on your AA rotation though. But I'm wondering if Carr isn't going to shift to the pen? The velocity and K's haven't really been great. He might be better in the Pen? Nowlin is also one of my favorite "is anyone paying attention to this guy" prospects. IF he can get a little more consistent, he's a viable back end rotation arm, maybe with #3 potential. I think he's a potential stud pen LH option if the rotation just doesn't turn out.

I've watched Wallner enough to see he has a pretty good eye, that's why he walks so much. I've seen him shorten up his swing and make adjustments and still drive the ball. And I've followed him throughout his milb career and monitored his numbers, and he constantly improved month to month at every level to he advanced to. But that's an eye test, not numbers. 12 games, 43 PA at Cedar Rapids in 2019 is the only time he's been under .800 for an OPS and it was .794. And it was for 2 weeks. His 4 year career MILB quad slash line: .274 AVG/ .361 OB%/ .511 SLG%/ .898 OPS. As I posted in a different OP regarding Wallner, take all 4 of those numbers and cut them by 30 points. Even 40 if you want. That's still a hell of a powerful and productive ballplayer. He's off to a good start with his 2022-2023 seasons. I can't wait to watch more. Does his early success and milb numbers offer proof he's going to be good? Absolutely not. But when you have a talented athlete who puts up big numbers everywhere he goes, wouldn't you want that as a starting point?? He's actually pretty fast and runs well, he's just a big guy who takes a second to get going. He's got that cannon of an arm. He's barely played LF, but he looked like he was getting more and more confident there last year. In 2025 he's probably in his more familiar RF, where his arm plays even better, and where he'll actually have a little less ground to cover. Defensively, the only real issue I've seen is some bad recognition and some bad routes here and there. He works on those things and gets better, he can be average defensively, and above average with the arm factored in. As far as LF in 2025, that will take care of itself. But, FWIW, I'm betting it might be Martin as the primary, and he'd help cover CF for Buxton. Castro will play LF, and Larnach might yet turn out as a corner OF/DH for us. But that's a whole year away yet.

If Varland does end up with the Saints to begin the season, I wonder if that bumps Canterino down to AA initially? Considering what he did in AA last time he was healthy, the argument can easily be made he should begin at AAA. But might Wichita be a little warmer maybe? Maybe coming off surgery and so much missed time, maybe he gets the first month there to warm up and get in a groove? Just speculating. I'd love to see him at AAA, but just wonder about a numbers crunch to begin with. Same with Pierson Ohl, who I don't think will be at AA for very long.

Despite what turned out to be a mild shoulder injury to end his 2023 on a downer note, the key, IMO, for Kirilloff has ALWAYS been the wrist issue, which seems to have been solved FINALLY via his last surgery. He was brought along a little slowly last season to give him ample time to ramp up and make sure his wrist was strong. When he came back, he hit at the top of the order almost daily, primarily in the 3 spot, but with a mix at the 2 and 4 spots as well. He hit, and he flashed power and production. He also appeared to be a more mature hitter in that he was suddenly walking at a higher rate than previous seasons. Unless SOMETHING ELSE happens, I'm expecting/hoping he has the best ML season of his career this year, and I believe he's a fixture for the next few years in the lineup. The guy can flat out hit. In 2021 Alcala was OK the first half of the year, but a bit of a tease. He'd flash, but then not look so good his next time out, or the 2nd inning in the same game appearance. A fair amount of that was LH batters. His second half of the season he seemed to really develop his change. And the results were pretty dramatic. His second half ERA dropped almost 2 full points. His AVERAGE-AGAINST and OBP dropped about 50 points each. And his SLG and OPS dropped about 180 and 206 points respectively. That's why there was a ton of optimism for him for 2022 and beyond. Now, does that mean he would maintain that kind of newly found success against the opposition? No. But it really looked like he was turning in to a valuable part of the pen, even a potential set up man. Cue 2years of injuries and missed opportunity. But now he's healthy and throwing high 90's again? I can't help but have a lot of optimism for him at this point. I'm hopeful for Miranda, though I agree he has the hardest fit with the team, at least for now. They key to Miranda when he was in the minors was STILL making contact, but to ignore weak contact and wait for loud contact opportunities. In 2021 he did that and made himself a top prospect. During his rookie 2022 season, for the most part, he maintained that approach and was very successful and teased for more in the future. Last season, with a bad shoulder, loss of strength, and maybe even some frustration and desperation, the loud contact disappeared and he started nubbing and popping out on every high and outside pitch he saw, bringing back the weak contact he was too often looking for in his early prospect days. In limited action so far this spring, it really is starting to look like the 2021-2022 Miranda is back, or on his way to being so. Unfortunately, his path to playing time right now is blocked by the veteran Santana. IDK, maybe Miranda gets all the way back and becomes a very nice trade chip to someone else, obviously after getting some quality ML time. Maybe he split his season between St Paul and the Twins and takes over for Santana in 2025...if not before...as a RH 1B/DH/PH who you could still sneak in at 3B here and there during the season. If he hits like he's shown he can...if not better...the Twins will find room for him. It's a little hard to answer WHEN, but they'll find room for him. OR, he might be on his way as part of a deal at some point.

Not going to speculate on how good or bad DeSclafini is going to be this season. The question is his readiness for 2024. His sore elbow was apparently just that, sore, as the Twins didn't feel it was anything warranting imaging. He threw a 35 pitch bullpen on Saturday the 9th with normal effort, as he did a smaller session, also with full effort, on Monday the 4th. I read somewhere that as long he was fine after the 9th, he was probably getting a start, which should mean this sometime this week. If that holds true, he should get in 3 starts before the season begins. After that, he can work with the team, or stay in Ft Myers and get in a 4th start against minor leaguers to continue his ramp up. Should the Twins skip him the first 10 days, the other 4 starters will all perform on either normal or extra rest. So unless Disco has a setback of some sort, I don't see any issue. The only question would be whether it's better to have DeSclafini work with the team, or keep him in Florida for a few more days and run with an extra pen arm for those few days. IF there's any health setback, THEN we have more to talk about.

I like to think I'm smart enough and have enough perspective on things to not get stuck on hype trains. Now, I can be a bit of an optimist. And I don't think it's climbing on board the hype train to be optimistic about this pen. As has been pointed out already, it's really hard to predict any individual in a pen, or a pen at large, from year to year. A couple bad weeks can ruin a month, etc. But I like the depth of possibilities this current incarnation of the pen holds. I honestly have no questions about Duran or Jax that you wouldn't have for any reliever. I believe in Stewart a lot and even if he regresses some...he will...he's really good. But can he go 50-60 IP this year? Thielbar had a nice 2023 and threw as hard as ever, and was K-ing over 10 per inning. He appears to still have some gas in the tank. He just needs to avoid nuisance injuries like pulled muscles, similar to last year. I have faith in Topa because breakout season or not, we see it. Stewart was an example last year. And Topa did it for a lot of innings. I don't know that he's anything more than a really nice 6th-7th inning guy, but I'd take that in a heartbeat. Okert has been successful for a few years now, and was pretty good in 2023 as well, despite a higher ERA than before. (ERA is obviously not the best way to measure a pen arm). His whipping, almost side arm delivery adds deception to his stuff, and as long as he doesn't leave something straight and over the middle, his stuff is pretty nasty most of the time. If Staumont can regain even 90% of his previous form, what a great signing! I can't say I have a lot of faith in Jay Jackson. He went to Japan to get his career going and his results, but even in relatively SSS, he was good in 2023. He's a complete flier. But he didn't cost anything but a minimum deal, so why not give him a shot and see? I like Funderburk and I have strong hopes for Alcala. I haven't given up on the young Henriquez now that's fully transitioned to the pen, as long as he's healthy. (he fought injuries in 2023). And there's a chance the non-roster Duarte can help even as one of the last 2 arms in the pen. Of course, there are other options available to help and certainly don't have to run through all of them and all possibilities. But there is often strength in numbers to give you the most ammunition, the most possibilities to choose from. Who we have, and the numbers we have, fill me with optimism.

Thanks for the great breakdown! I think we all can agree, other than an IL for Desclafini, Varland begins the year at AAA, right or wrong, as Ober did a year ago. SWR and Canterino the same, though Cantetino MIGHT get some early AA time, IMO, in what might be slightly better weather to just his "groove on" plus a potential initial roster crunch at AAA as they sort out the arms there. Personally, I'd rather they just jettison some of the milb FA they brought in and just make room. What your list proposes is the Twins have ONE bullpen spot available to begin the season, everyone healthy and ready to go, including Disco, who is a wait and see despite reports he's throwing and going to be ready. Despite options or no options, barring an injury, Duran, Jax, Stewart, Thielbar, Topa are all locks. And I'd say deservedly so. Okert has a solid history and is also a probable deserving lock. That's 6 of 8 bullpen spots. You're right when we talk about the last spot, or two, being flexible for bullpen rotation. But if you have a solid rotation and pen, does that flexibility matter? Sands spent most of 2023 as a sacrificial lamb who barely threw at the ML level at times. So who fills the final 2 spots in the pen? Well, the re-invented Jay Jackson went overseas to find himself. And he has not options. And he did well for the Jay's last year. But his $ is negligible. So if he stinks, he costs next to nothing to let someone else to take his spot. How many others have we seen DFA the past few seasons and then go back to St Paul? But Jackson is certainly a candidate to make the roster if he's actually showing something. And why not? Not to sound disheartened, but he'd be an easy DFA if things don't turn out. Can Staumont get his game together? If he can, he was a tremendous signing. If he needs more time, how do the Twins make that work? And he does have an option. Meanwhile, there are the arms of Alcala and Funderburk, and maybe someone like Henriquez sitting and waiting. I DON'T agree the Twins have assembled some pen with no options. Point in fact there ARE pen arms with options, and only a couple of arms without options that could be easy DFA options for the last couple of spots if they don't produce.

Really curious as to why you think the Twins preference is to have "a bunch of players bad at playing all positions"? 8 position players who are pretty much locked in. 4 "bench" players once we remove the backup/#2 catcher. That's 9 spots spoken for. Castro is solid to good everywhere, and solid offensively. Farmer cover 3/4 of the INF with solid defense, solid but not great offense, and could be pressed in to service at 1B and LF if really needed to do so in crunch time. Margot is an OK offensive player who has a really good reputation defensively, despite a couple of injuries the past couple of seasons that slowed him. Santana, not my favorite offseason acquisition, is a good 1B who HOPEFULLY has 1 more year of a solid bat still in him, at least against LHP, until Miranda, or maybe Severino is ready to displace him. If you want to object to certain players at certain positions as being poor, thats your perogative. And that's a whole different debate that i would gladly persue. But an arguement of "bad at all positions" in regard to the roster is not only an obscure blanket statement, but one that would appear obtuse in regard to many of the players already on hand.

Yep. But I do agree with JD-Twins that if Goodrum...all due respect to a previous Twins soldier coming home...is up, something has gone wrong for the season. Goodrum is a Garlick kind of add and promotion and sent back down after clearing waivers. Lee added to the 40 man, or Martin brought up would seem more plausible. Just saying.

I also appreciate good defense. I think it's somewhat undervalued in today's game. But in reference to Lee, I think it's widely accepted that he has the ability to be a solid ML SS. Not great, but solid. And I have no doubt that he'd be a great 3B. And I have no doubt Lewis would be a great 2B. And MAYBE that's how it will play out ultimately. But I also have no doubt that Lewis can be, and will be, an excellent 3B. And if Lee is a good, solid SS, why can't HE be a great 2B? And maybe, just maybe, the Twins would prefer that alignment not only because Lewis is already looking good at 3B, but maybe they don't want his repaired knee at 2B potentially getting undercut by a hard slide? I think the issue of defensive flexibility is often misleading. Let's use Solano last season. He played 1B/2B/3B. (He used to play SS). He wasn't great at any spot. But he could play all 3 without embarrassing himself to be sure. But he was a role player who ended up playing more than expected. And he did a good job overall. Next, let's look at Castro. Everyone keeps calling him an OF. But he's also a good 3B/2B who has looked just fine playing SS at times. And he brings a lot to the team WITH that versatility and a decent bat, with speed and SB ability. But he's not going to dislodge anyone in the normal starting 9 unless his offense suddenly explodes. Farmer, pretty much the same. Just saying a guy could be put at a spot doesn't mean defensive versatility. My goodness, Kirilloff was originally a CF in HS. That was 8yrs ago. Sano and Arraez were originally SS! You wouldn't dare play any of those guys at their age 18yo positions! But guys need rest, and guys get hurt. And depth isn't just milb depth, it's also versatility to move guys around as needed so the next man up can fit in. EXAMPLE: Lee covers 4 positions. He can cover 3B/SS/2B if needed, and that allows Julien to move to 1B if needed, a position he's played before, still works at, and could continue to play in the future. Martin, primarily an INF in college is nothing more than an emergency SS if all he'll breaks loose in a game. His future is in the OF. In fact, I'm of the belief that in 2025 he might be the PRIMARY LF and the top Buxton backup in CF. But if he can actually play a good 2B, and a competent 3B, it just means he's a versatile player depending on need. Once he establishes himself in the OF as a PRIMARY starter, and considering the depth the Twins have, I don't know that you'd ever see him on the dirt again except for an emergency situation. But like Lee, the more he can do as a ROOKIE awaiting his opportunity, gives the entire roster more flexibility when injuries and issues happen. Sometimes stuff happens. I've seen former Twin Rosario play 3B in an extra inning game. Vazquez isn't a bad 1B when things happen. Kirillof is a 1B but can be OK in an OF corner here and there because he's played it and isn't a complete statue. Lee WILL find his spot. I believe Martin WILL find his spot, though there is a CHANCE he could become an EVERY DAY REGULAR who plays multiple spots similar to a young Marwin Gonzalez. VERSATILITY isn't a bad thing. It's about having as many good players and good bats as you can have, and fitting all the pieces together. But for PROSPECTS, it's about finding out where you can comfortably play them while they're getting established. It's about depth and versatility of talent, and not just plugging someone in somewhere with a glove and told to do your best.

Just want to add, Farmer's role on the team is a solid, veteran backup at 3 spots, and probable quasi-platoon at 2B with Julien. The fact that he could handle 1B or LF in a pinch isn't even much of a factor. He has his role. If...knock on wood....Correa had some sort of injury that kept him out for an extended time, the Twins would probably put Lee at SS and keep Farmer in his current role.

But honestly, how else do you build a pen without throwing tons of $ to FA and hope they don't become injured or flame out? SOME relievers are simply relievers almost from the day they're drafted, but that's a small minority. Most are starters that are converted at some point, often at the AAA and ML level. On the current roster that's true of Duran, Jax, and Stewart. Thielbar was a mediocre SP who was pretty much out of baseball when he got a second chance and has thrived. Alcala and the very interesting Funderburk are former starters. Topa has a nice track record at the ML level as does Okert. I don't see them as cast offs. And if you look at the history of Twins' pens, there are many other good examples I'm not going to list. But think of former Twin Liam Hendricks. He washed out as a SP, disappeared, and then reimerged as a an excellent closer. You don't find a Hendricks, or a Stewart, until or unless you take fliers on some arms and see what you have. I don't think for a moment that every arms signed by the Twins are going to come through. Some of those fliers are scheduled to be at AAA and aren't even on the 40 man. Jay Jackson is someone who rebuilt his career oversees, came back, and performed well for the Jay's last year in a SSS. If he does well with the Twins, do we care how he got here? What you're looking for...and to be honest every team does this...is hopefully 1 or 2 finds a year. They might be good for 1 season, or multiple seasons. But the more options you have, the better your odds of success.

That changes things a bit for sure. I kind of like. But I rather like Ash's idea of him going to the IL if he's not fully recovered yet. I.E. he is technically recovering from surgery. If velocity isn't back yet, etc, could he be placed on the IL to continue some rehab work, get in to rehab games at AAA, and play the wait and see game and not use the option? Not sure as to how some of the rules in that regard work. But he was really good with KC before the injuries happened. And he's not exactly old. It would be nice to be able to give him more time, if possible, to get right.

I keep thinking the last half of 2021 was when Alcala really hit his stride. But according the the OP, it was 2020. But my memory and a Baseball Reference look up tells me it was the last half of 2021 where he seemed to really figure out his change up and that made all the difference in the world. First half of 2021 was a 4.67 ERA and 8.0K per 9. His second half was a 2.88 ERA and 10.8 K per 9. That was when the change became a real weapon and he looked to be a bullpen fixture for the next few years. And then came 2yrs of injuries. Late last year, it was reported he was throwing in the 97-98mph range again. His winter performance, though SSS, looked really good. So far so good this spring. With other veterans brought in and him still having an option, it's possible he opens at St Paul no matter what. But I don't think that last spot is set in the pen just yet either. Regardless, I think he's going to step forward and grab a spot and never let it go...provided the good health is for real and maintains.

So THINK what you're asking about is HOW the Twins are approaching who plays where? I think we've seen since day one that the FO/Twins want a team that has a lot of positional flexibility whenever possible. That allows for coverage at different spots when someone needs a day off, or someone is injured, and to always put together the best roster and lineup on a daily basis, even as the names change day to day. But when you have Lewis on the club and penciled in to 3B, I think the Twins already know he could slide to SS in a pinch if needed. They could probably toss him out to LF or CF in a pinch and just feel confident he'd be OK, or at least not embarrass himself. But there's no reason to do that when someone else on the team can do those jobs. Meanwhile, the question on someone like Martin and Lee isn't so much about making them any sort of permanent utility player, but it's more about where is their opportunity to play once promoted to the roster. In other words, they might feel Lee is going to play 2B as the primary player there...eventually...and Julien will cover there, and 1B, and DH. But if Lewis or Correa went down for any length of time, Farmer and Castro would probably not be the fill in, it would be Lee. So they see certain guys as "regulars" in the lineup as they are great players. Even though they can play other positions, there isn't always a reason to do so. I mean, Wallner can cover Kepler in RF and Castro or Margot can play LF if they think that's the best lineup. But you certainly could just keep Wallner in LF and place someone else in RF. But when you move around Lee and Martin, it's to see where the best opportunity is for them to be called up, make the club, stick with the club, etc. EVENTUALLY, Lee is probably up and starting at 2B daily, as previously mentioned. That doesn't mean he can't slide to SS to cover for Correa for a day off and Julien play 2B. I think there's a reasonable chance Martin is the "primary" starting LF next season after Kepler is gone and Wallner moves to RF. But that doesn't mean he can't play CF to give Buxton a day off. Not sure how Martin at 2B figures in the future, and maybe it doesn't, unless he just turns out to be an EVERY DAY player, but who plays everywhere, much like Marwin Gonzalez was back in the day. So there's PRIMARY players who can play other spots but don't really need to very often. And then there's kids on the way up who can play different spots so they are going to do so to provide roster flexibility and greater opportunity for promotion and depth coverage UNTIL they establish themselves at a PRIMARY position, as one of those PRIMARY players. Of course, there's always going to be those guys who are good ballplayers, productive players, who just aren't special enough with what they do to challenge those PRIMARY players' production on a daily basis, so they will simply always be a super utility player. Think Castro vs Lewis for instance. So I think it's a layered approach. Does that make sense?

First game to watch and didn't care it was ST. It was just nice to see any version of Twins baseball! A few personal observations: 1] Varland didn't destroy anything, but looked solid. I think he could have gone out for the 4th easily, but they obviously wanted to follow a plan. I saw his new 2 seamer really BITE few times against RH bats that lead to 3 outs. I want to say one was a K out, but memory is failing me right now. He was sitting consistently at 94-96 on his FB. His only real mistake was over reacting to a slow nubber down the 1B line that would probably have rolled foul. 2] Helman's bat hasn't come around yet, which I find disappointing, but he looked really good at 2B when he went in for Juien early after a pitch to the hand. Julien was flexing his hand after being hit, so hopefully he's OK. 3] Martin made a tough circus catch early in the game in LF due to a bright sky and strange winds. He also snagged a deep fly to left center that wasn't easy. And while the camera work in the game was horrible and no replay was seen, he had a great hustle play where he grabbed an OF grounder and fired a throw to 2B to nail the runner trying for 2B. Offensively, he was screwed by an umpire team that seemed to believe anything close to a swing was a strike. But he also stroked a nice double to LF. 4] Larnach hit a HR to RF that had the distance, but was almost blown back in to fair territory. What's interesting is the pitch coming in at 85mph. Not sure if it was a change or slider, but he hit it solid. Another FB resulted in a solid single. 5] Only 1 game, but Staumont was wild as hell. I think he topped out around 93. After a mound visit, he settled down and got out of the inning and looked better. But I'm wondering if his last option might still e used to let him get his velocity and stuff to get right at AAA. But again, it's ST and we still have a couple weeks. 6] I can see how affective Okert might be. His "almost" sidearm delivery is crazy! It's gotta be really hard to pick up the ball coming out of his hand. He looked good and I believe he K'd 3. But he did allow a couple hits. But unless he throws something straight in the zone, he's pretty nasty. 7] Sands disappointed me facing the leftovers from Pittsburgh. To be fair, there was a wild pitch that a better catcher MIGHT have snagged. But he just didn't look like the OK, SOLID BP option that I think/hope he might be. Again, ONE ST GAME, for what it's worth.