If I was the GM (thankfully for all, I am not)....I'd not extend one starter, and use that money to sign Nola (if he's still a FA).
Nola, Ryan, Lopez, Ober, Winder, Varland, SWR, et. al. looks like a pretty good rotation to me.
I think people in this thread are replying to the idea he faced top pitching in the AFL, which the article implied, but isn't close to true. I think people, most of them, are tempering their excitement given that. Some clearly aren't believers, but some are.
Not according to half the articles on this site. If the player isn't perfect, its just too risky. Also, if they don't develop players and play them, they are stupid. So, um, good luck?
Those stats would make him a borderline number two starter....
I'm a believer. I think he's a legit number three, four, starter right now. He'll be in the rotation full time next year.
He could play left field defensively with no issue. Probably only needs a few weeks at second base. He'd be a good center fielder. I am not sure I understand your post
Farmer is the backup SS this year.....I admit not knowing who it is after that. I think any of Lewis/Lee/someone else could play there 20-40 games a year if needed, even if their primary position was elsewhere. I'd guess, not knowing, they would be like Polanco was defensively, fine given their O.
I think Lewis should be in CF and RF going forward (as I think Lee is your 3B going forward).
I'd put Martin in LF/CF/2B. I'd put Julien at 2B/1B, I think.
Given Martin's speed, it would be great to have him around for the 10th inning.....
A bunch of people on a website say that.....I doubt the Twins say that. And, as you say, it is bad advice to the coach. I'm not sure what your argument is?
They tried to improve his swing. It didn't work. You don't fire someone for trying to make someone better. It seems to be working for a ton of AA players......sometimes things don't work. Then you adjust your approach with that player.
Which player on last year's roster should have tried to steal more? If you aren't successful 80% of the time, you are giving up runs.
As for Martin, I'm still a believer. However, he didn't face anywhere near good pitching in the AFL. Most analysts compare the pitching there to AA or lower.
Good thing you weren't the GM when Hunter struggled. Miranda was a rookie. He might not be great at third, but to write him off after one year is amazingly impatient.