I see the other side of it too -- having a relief ace available every game is a nice weapon, but in practical terms it's unlikely to work out that well. A starter is always a factor -- a reliever may or may not be, due to circumstances entirely out of his control. In the conference tournament this year, which Illinois entered as the #1 seed, they went 2-2 and lost in the semifinals, with Jay making only 2 appearances in 4 games -- a 1 inning, 1 run save, and the last 1.1 innings of the final game (a 2-run loss). In the regional tournament, Jay appeared only once and it was impressive (4 shutout innings) but it ultimately wasn't critical as they swept their double-elimination bracket in 3 games. In the super regional, they lost 13-0 in the opener to face elimination. Then, in the elimination game, they asked Jay to make only his second career start (his first being a non conference tune-up on Feb. 15), and asked him to pitch a career high 6.1 innings. And he lost it by giving up 5 hits and the 2 go-ahead runs in the 6th and 7th inning, before departing with 1 out and 2 runners on in the 7th. It doesn't look like the greatest management of resources.