True, if you only look at June, and every player is prone to slumps sometime. But it's not just June for Joe. For the month of May: Top 10 3B: .312/.381/.570, .951 OPS Mauer: .240/.278/.340, .618 OPS Hunter: .333/.391/.566, .957 OPS April was much better for Joe, but even that was only an .804 OPS. When that's your "peak" month, you might be closer to .700 OPS "true talent" level, which isn't good out of a lineup fixture at 1B. Also, Joe has just looked lost at the plate lately. Taking pitches he shouldn't, etc.