Watching the O's A's: was wondering about Tim Beckham and discovered he was #1 overall 2008. Rays gave him away much like the Twins gave away Hicks....tie-in, it was also the year the Twins drafted Hicks! So, looking at 1st round 2008 the standout is Posey, 8th overall by SF and 3 WS championships later. However, sorted by WAR, I found these results: 1. Posey 37 2. Lawrie 15 3. Lynn 14 4. Hosmer 13 5. Forsythe 12 6. Cole 11.7 7. Jason Castro 11.6 8. Chisenhall 9 ... 15. Hicks 5 We got the catcher we needed, just not in the trade. Here's to Castro, better than Beckham(who started the thread) at 5 WAR, Smoak, Cashner, Alonso, Crow, etc. He ain't chopped liver. BTW, Castro was 10th overall that year by Houston, and Hicks was 14th.