Graham and Tonkin are similar in that they have fastballs that have little movement and don't control their breaking pitches that well. Especially in this day and age, 95 mile per hour fastballs that are straight won't get many guys out. I'm not saying that they can't make it but I think people are too enamored by the fact that they throw harder than what we've had a in the pen.
No thanks on Zobrist but I'm interested in Clippard. At this point the other trade the Twins should make is to send the Braves a warm body for Graham. They can then option him to Rochester and bring up somebody with a chance. I'm not a big believer in Tonkin but he would be a clear improvement over Graham at this point.
I wouldn't even trade him for a SS; only for a catcher. We've got enough options at SS that I think it will work out. We KNOW we have a problem behind the plate.
Yep, but I wouldn't even bother on the rental. Whoever they would get it not going to be much better than Suzuki. Not worth giving up even mediocre prospect and upsetting the pitching apple cart.
Despite his current struggles, I'm not trading Santana for a rental return. Polanco is really struggling in the field and likely ends up at second base. Since we have Dozier, I am more likely to trade Polanco than Santana.
I think the most realistic scenario for a trade for a young catcher with potential likely involves Plouffe this winter. Plouffe with a good, but not our top prospects gets it done.
I guess my first thought is that our bullpen is our most glaring weakness. As much as I would like to upgrade the catching situation, there is far greater potential for improvement by upgrading the bullpen than there is by upgrading at catcher and at a lesser price. The reality is that there are very few good catchers out there - I think people will be shocked at what the price is in terms of trades. That's one reason I'm not interested in Lucroy. We would have to pony up some of our best prospects and we are guaranteed to only have him for a couple of years. Just too expensive.
If there is a goat, it's Susuki. The "wild pitch' charged to Perk was pretty lame, if you are going to contribute you have to come up with the pitch. The steal of third can't happen against a quality catcher.
I really don't understand the love for Ossie if you throw him a cookie he'll mash it. Other than that he's a liability. Not suited to be an occasional bench bat.
I completely agree with your observations about the ability to get a strikeout when needed. I think the concern with bringing him in the middle of an inning is that he would have to get ready in a really short period of time (even compared to when they know he will start an inning clean) and if he can't do it, then the risk of injury goes way up. None of us want to see that.