I also said everything you said is pretty much true, so that should probably answer the question. That said, two basic stats about May as a starter that need to be continually mentioned (and not just excused away) - Leaving aside Nolasco who is out for the year, May has averaged the fewest innings per start and has given up the most runs per inning as a starter. That is about as basic as it gets, so I don't exactly think he is a slam dunk guy in the rotation. I do think he is likely to be one of best (certainly no worse than 4th) going forward, but it wasn't an atrocity at the time.