We could go round and round on this. If analytics were the end all be all then guys like Mike Yaztremski who toiled in the minors for years would never be heard of. Or Wade who was claimed by the Giants and had a great 2021 season. How about Rooker. I think he has 6 homers 4 vs righthanders. In Minnesota if he was dh it was primarily vs lefties. How is that possible when the analytics say he has an x% chance of doing so. And turns it upside down. Those analytics give projections. They are right sometimes but players need ample opportunities to establish a base line. And the variables aren't a constant either. Brian Kenny. King of analytics says wins aren't important. How so. If a pitcher is able to keep his team in let's just say 25 out of 30 starts and goes 18-5 like Verlander did last year. How can wins not be important. Sure sometimes you'll get big run production and have an off day and still get a win, but that's not the norm. He also says RBIs are over valued. If a guy drives in 100 runs, he's doing something right.. Today's analytics are given to the GMs for negotiating contracts. And they will focus on all of the negatives. The agents will have the same numbers and their focus will point out all of the positives. Arreaz is another guy. High avg high obp and not much else Is what the Twins would say, but this year his slugging % is way up too. So which player is he? And I never said that these guy who collect and analyse the data are non baseball guys. Or unathletic. Every manager since the invention of baseball has had a book on players and their tendencies. It's just every so often they'd have a hunch and play off that hunch. That's not allowable today. If you don't follow the book, you'll be out of a job. I'm not anti Rocco either. I believe his hands are tied and most in game decisions are determined before the 1st pitch in daily meetings with Falvey and Levine. Have you ever noticed how the Twins don't post a lineup until a couple hours before the game. So unless you're Buxton or Correa the players don't know either. And I know that for a fact.