Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

TopGunn#22

Verified Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2,385

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

 Content Type 

Profiles

News

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospects Ranking

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

Minnesota Twins Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

The Minnesota Twins Players Project

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Pick Tracker

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by TopGunn#22

  1. TopGunn#22
    Yeah...Atlanta is a LITTLE farther EAST than Pittsburgh...
  2. TopGunn#22
    I'd put Perranoski at #5. Everyday Eddie #4. Reardon #2. Aggie #2 and Joe Nathan #1. Nathan was simply outstanding. He had some tough outcomes in a couple of playoff series, but to me, Nathan is the #1 reliever of all time for the Twins. Taylor Rogers, with 4-5 good seasons could crack the top 5.
  3. TopGunn#22
    I was reading thru the comments and I almost couldn't believe nobody was mentioning how close Minneapolis came to landing the Giants before Dodgers owner Walter O'Malley convinced Giants owner Horace Stoneman to move to San Francisco to keep the legendary Dodgers-Giants rivalry intact. Thank You Old Time and Sky Blue !!!
  4. TopGunn#22
    JLease. Good Points ! I will not change my mind, and would probably even place Pascual ahead of Radke, but I see the points your making and accept your argument to a certain degree.
  5. TopGunn#22
    I have a problem with Radke even being on the list. He's got longevity numbers but everything about Radke was "average." He was "solid" but he was never "great." For me, Jim Perry is #5 and move Kaat and Viola up. Perry won a Cy Young in 1970, and was our #1 or #2 for much of the 60's. Kaat should have wona Cy Young in 1966 (there was only one award for AL/NL then and who was going to beat Sandy Koufax) ?? And I agree with the idea that if you're talking "Franchise" Walter Johnson is #1. But I think this article was meant "TWINS only." #5 Jim Perry #4 Jim Kaat #3 Frank Viola That's what makes #1 so tough. Blyleven has the longevity numbers and a lot more. Santana wasn't just the twins Ace in his prime, he was one of baseball's top 2 or 3. I look at Santana as the Twins version of Sandy Koufax (without the World Series appearances) so I'll put Santana #1 and Bert #2.
  6. TopGunn#22
    I'll stick with Mauer #1. To do what he did as a catcher is remarkable. #2 on my list is Killebrew. He did all that while playing OUT OF POSITION so the team could get Rich Reese's bat (and glove) in the lineup 49 HR's in the decade of the pitcher along with 140 RBI's is pretty darn impressive. #3 Would be Carew. Tremendous season. #4 & #5 are also tough. Morneau beat out a fellow SS in Jeter, so I'm kind of inclined to give the nod to Morneau (and I'm a child of the 60's and 70's so I've got nothing against Zoilo).
  7. TopGunn#22
    Tony-O is my favorite Twins player, but Zoilo was the right choice. I do think that if Tony-O had won that MVP award he would probably already be in the HOF. MVP awards carry weight. There was an interesting article about the controversial MVP Mo Vaughn won over Albert Bell. Bell's stats were not just better, they were MUCH better. Bell had an epic season but the writers didn't like him and he'd been caught corking his bat the year before.
  8. TopGunn#22
    Spot on Doc. Depending on who they are looking to acquire as a stud SP (and I have to admit, I've been pushing for Chris Sale and Syndergaard DOH !!) the Twins are better off keeping both Larnach and Kiriloff. I could see a scenario for 2021 where Cruz has retired or moved on, Sano becomes a DH who occasionally plays 1B, Rosario is traded and there's Larnach in LF and Kiriloff at 1B. Both these kids will HIT. Of that I have little doubt.
  9. TopGunn#22
    And I TOTALLY agree with Stringer Bell. Tony-O was and is my favorite all time Twin. You hear the guys that had to play against him, especially the pitchers (Jim Palmer, Denny McClain, Catfish Hunter) they all think he should be in there.
  10. TopGunn#22
    I would put Puckett ahead of Hrbek on the all time list. I think overall it's a good list. But for a guy to be considered, he needs more than just a couple seasons like Hisle or Bostock. First some corrections: Oliva didn't win the batting title in the Twins inaugural season. That was 1961. Tony-O won the batting title and Rookie of the Year in 1964 and then finished 2nd to Zoilo for the American League MVP in 1965 in helping lead the Twins to the American League pennant. I think the point that Killebrew hit homers (LOTS of them) in an era where HR's were generally hard to come by is excellent. (I think Indiana made that point). I would go with Killebrew #1 and Carew #2 and be thrilled I got to watch both of them play.
  11. TopGunn#22
    I asked my wife. She's FAR more qualified to comment than me. Kepler---Runaway Winner. The line about him being ABC's next Bachelor hits the nail on the head. Otherwise, she says Eddie Rosario and Taylor Rogers should be higher. She also noted that Alex Kiriloff is a fine looking young man so Eddie has ANOTHER reason to be worried.
  12. TopGunn#22
    I think Larnach and Kiriloff should BOTH start seeing more games in LF. I'm not sure if they will be on the same team/level to begin this minor league season, but if they are, they should alternate starting in LF & RF. In a very limited look, I saw Kiriloff play some 1B in a spring training game and he looked decent (which means he didn't make any bone-headed plays). Kiriloff and Larnach are READY to hit at the big league level.
  13. TopGunn#22
    GREAT article !! It's easy to get lost in all the prospects not named Kiriloff, Lewis or Larnach. I think BOTH Kiriloff and Larnach are going to be very good major league hitters. It's why Eddie Rosario's days are probably numbered even if his defense rebounds somewhat and he has a good year hitting this year. When extensions for Berrios, Buxton, Sano, Arraez etc...start to come an affordable LF'er will be necessary. Question about Jeffers...is he a left handed hitter ? I seem to remember him being a right handed hitter but if he's a lefty it would make for an awesome platoon with Garver.
  14. TopGunn#22
    I agree, I wouldn't have included Thorpe. I would have mulled the following players for that #3 spot: Mitch Garver. He was SO GOOD last year. Can he even come close to what he did ? Jorge Polanco. He started at SS in the All Star Game. Have you seen how many really GOOD SS's there are in the American league ?? Max Kepler. Last year he put everything together and bashed 36 HR's. Can he do it again ? Tyler Duffy/Trevor May. The guys were light out over the 2nd half of the season. Can they be even better ?? When a team wins 101 games and sets a record for HR's in a season it's hard to come up with "conventional" X-Factors. Garver, Kepler, Polanco and many others had the BEST seasons of their careers. How do they follw that up in 2020 ?? It's going to be so much fun to see.
  15. TopGunn#22
    Oh, I think the Dodgers and Yankees both win about 108 games.
  16. TopGunn#22
    This looks pretty good. I'm actually surprised at how high the Astros win total is. I could see the Twins winning more (98-100 games) and the Astros winning less (94-95). Interesting that this is the year the Reds finally break through and win the division. I still like the Braves in the N.L. East. Braves 92-70 Mets 90-72 Nats 86-76
  17. TopGunn#22
    Totally agree Richard. Not only do we have Larnach, but Kiriloff as well. I don't dislike Rosario, but with talent like that coming up behind him Eddie is eminently replaceable.
  18. TopGunn#22
    mikelink !! That's a GREAT comparison. I've been thinking about Buxton's similarity to Pete Reiser for a long time. Reiser was a .300+ hitter, very fast and a super aggressive outfielder. He played CF for Brooklyn in the 40's. I agree that PECOTA is a little harsh toward Buxton but remember, Buxton's sample size is pretty small and I can see how PECOTA could project him this way. However, Twins fans who watched a lot of games last year saw a completely different approach at the plate from Buxton (and Sano for that matter as well). Maybe it was the influence of Nelson Cruz (I don't think it was a coincidence). It seemed that Buxton and Sano each had a definite "plan" in mind while at the plate last year. This is where PECOTA comes up short...the eye test. As with Pete Reiser, so with Buxton. If he can stop crashing into outfield walls and play 140-150 games we will really enjoy seeing Buxton's "baseball gifts" for the better part of an entire season.
  19. TopGunn#22
    This is a much better deal if Balazovic is not included. he will be a very good front line starter for the Twins.
  20. TopGunn#22
    Deeper starting staff. Solid bullpen that will be one of the A.L.'s best. A lineup that will score, score and SCORE.
  21. TopGunn#22
    5 for $60 would be acceptable. For the foreseeable future he is the Ace of the staff. If the Twins ever figure out how to pair him with a true #1 he would be a good #2. Get it done.
  22. TopGunn#22
    This is a GREAT debate. I agree, let's visit this several times over the coming season. Clearly, you've identified the top 3 teams. But there are so many nuances with each lineup that it could be any of the 3. There will be a lot of "prove it" to me with the Astros lineup this year, but there is no doubt they have some studs. What the Yankees did last year offensively with all those injuries is terrifying. What if Stanton & Judge are healthy for a whole season? What if Andujar gets 550 AB's? (that kid can flat out HIT). What is the ceiling for Gleybor Torres? Can Urshela even come close to 2019? And on the Twins side...what if Buxton plays in 150 games? Can Garver repeat? What is the ceiling for Sano ? Can Cruz keep it up ? This season should be LOTS of FUN !!!
  23. TopGunn#22
    I still say if you want to deal with Boston substitute Sale for Price, get a better pitcher who is only 30 years old and have him for 5 years of team control. Sale becomes your #1. Price would probably be our #3. And even if it's only one year of Mookie, Kiriloff will be ready in 2021. We can certainly make a better offer than the Padres.
  24. TopGunn#22
    Salazar is the name that intrigues me the most. Him and/or Walker but only on minor league deals with something like a May 1st opt out. If Salazar could ever stay healthy...OH BOY. Back in his best days with the Indians his stuff was filty.
  25. TopGunn#22
    Kiriloff & Larnach will push Eddie out. There's a small chance it happens mid-late this season. An even greater chance it happens for 2021. Those 2 young guys can HIT, they are younger, cheaper, faster, etc... Enjoy Eddie this year, as i will. But when Kiriloff takes his spot in the lineup, take note, it will be fun.
×
×
  • Create New...