I don't see how you can send Milone down after how well he has pitched. Keep him in the rotation until he pitches himself out of it. I personally would like to see how he does the rest of the year. Other teams have 'crafty leftys' that seem to be able to win. Hughes and Santana, with the money they are making, are givens. Gibson is also a given. He's pitched well and is part of the future. Pelfrey has pitched too well to take him out. That leaves May. With that last dud he pitched himself out of the rotation. Sorry but thats the way competition works, you don't perform you're out. Put him in the pen, he could be really good there and can be moved back to a starter at a moments notice. Entertain offers for Pelfrey and Milone at the trade deadline, if its something good, trade one of them, other wise go with what I outlined above - Hughes, Santana, Pelfrey, Gibson, Milone, with May in reserve for the rest of the year.