Well, I like Kepler about as much as anyone does, but #1 is too high. When I look at stats, every player is entitled to one out-of-sight good year, and one shrug-your-shoulders bad year, each of which I want to reduce in importance to the overall picture I'm forming of his chances as he moves up in difficulty of opponents faced, and in the fullness of time Kepler's 2015 is likely to look very much like the former. A stats-only based approach is likely to weight the most recent season heavily, so I suppose I'm not surprised to see him fare well in this listing. But #1? Phew, that's pretty rare air up there.