tony&rodney
Old-Timey Member-
Posts
10,778 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
94
Content Type
Profiles
Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis
Minnesota Twins Videos
2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings
2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources
2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by tony&rodney
-
If Walker Jenkins is going to be a platoon player, it might be worthwhile to see if he can return a better player in a trade. I like the idea of adding two strong bullpen arms. Please add details of your guess at length of contracts. They are not signing for one year. How many years did you offer Bauers? He may take the QO from Milwaukee. Kody Clemens had a good year but I think the Twins want a better glove at second base and Clemens fits as a strong utility player. What happened to Wallner, Larnach, Ober? Did you send Rojas, Matthews, and Festa to AAA? The $135M budget gets tossed out here, which is an optimistic thought. This looks like $160M or so. C'mon Tommy Pohlad, do a $160M payroll. Thank you for submitting a blueprint.
-
4 Steps to Solving the Twins’ Catching Woes
tony&rodney replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Please stop with articles that involve Jeffers.- 23 replies
-
- ryan jeffers
- victor caratini
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Can someone start a petition to end all articles involving any discussion of Ryan Jeffers? This topic has been beat to death.
- 54 replies
-
- ryan jeffers
- david bednar
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
There have been so many articles on Jeffers. To your question, the response by comments submitted on Twins Daily can be broke down in to two areas. One is sign Jeffers, move him to DH/1B when Lackey arrives. The other is a combination of a) Jeffers will cost the Twins a shot at signing a star bullpen arm or bat; b) Jeffers is a good hitter but not a catcher or a first baseman or a good enough bat to just DH, plus the Twins may want to hold the DH spot open and the Twins need to improve their defense. Those are the two positions.
- 54 replies
-
- ryan jeffers
- david bednar
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
I have struggled to see a trade put forth that makes sense to me for Joe Ryan. I can see opportunities to complete trades where someone like Ober is traded along with a controllable player for a player that could fit into the Twins needs. The news we see concerning the lockout is primarily driven by the owners. The PA sits quietly by the sideline, except to react to big proposals by the owners. Collusion, as mentioned in a previous comment, would not surprising in the least. The owners agreeing not to do this or that until a resolution of the CBA is not likely a legal mistake unless specific emails, notes, and agreements are carelessly passed around. Of course, the teams failing to bolster their rosters through signings and trades reduces the quality of the game. I understand that everyone has opinions on this topic and some are strong. To me it has always seemed really simple. The owners want a CBA to put hard restrictions on all of the owners in a fashion which protects the cost/risk for every franchise. As a few owners have stated, the values of clubs should rise with controlled cost across the industry. Thus it is the players who should bail out the owners, agreeing to a cap system, to save the owners from their inability to agree amongst themselves on how to share revenues.
-
The Twins greatest risk they can possibly take is to continue to roll it back with the same basic group and fill the roster openings with a couple of plaid signings. What was the saying? Did anyone hear something about go big? There are opportunities for trades. A few of these can be simple or they can rock the joint a little bit. Free agents cost money and draft choices. A couple of bullpen arms and a bat are needed. How they add those pieces .... I don't care. The bat has to own a glove and have some power. Zoll needs to accomplish something substantial before the lockout or the Twins will fade further from the view of sports fans, leaving behind only us few old diehards. That sad number cannot support a franchise.
- 54 replies
-
- ryan jeffers
- david bednar
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Guess the payroll will be substantial if the Twins can entertain spending up to $10M on a utility player after first considering their needs at catcher, adding two good bullpen arms, and a bat for the right side of the infield. If the payroll goes to $170M, sure, add Dubon.
- 41 replies
-
- ryan kreidler
- jp crawford
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Signing Jeffers would be for him to play at the catcher position, hopefully for 110 games per season. Jeffers is not a first baseman and the Twins would use him sometimes at DH but they need that position for others about 80% of the time. If Jeffers isn't seen as a catcher, then the Twins should not be considering any contracts with him. The Twins already offered him the QO and he will make a decision in a week or so, but it makes sense for Jeffers to sign for the longer term money now if it is offered because catchers can get injured or decline very rapidly. I wish him well.
-
DJL44’s 2027 Payroll Blueprint: DJL44 - compete in 2027
tony&rodney replied to DJL44's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
In other words, a return to a few seasons ago in a way. Love watching Arraez hit but don't see him as a very productive bat and I do not buy the metrics on his glove. Lowe is a better bet. I'm not opposed to trading any or all of Ryan, Ober, Kremer for a return that makes the roster more talented, Zoll needs to get to work. -
This thread has a number of thoughtful comments covering a return of Jeffers versus the cost opportunity of that decision. It is easy to see the support for Jeffers and also easy the support for strengthening the roster elsewhere. It seems like these discussions always come back to budget and nobody appears to have any idea of even the range of where the roster expenditures will rest in 2027. The Opening Day payroll for last season was just under $105M. Most people would agree that a 25% increase is significant, which would put the number for 2027 around $131M. The voices of anger will scream (perhaps rightfully) about the past cuts. Thus I feel that the Twins should be considering a budget of $150M. A higher number, while sweet for addressing team needs, might not be supportable by resources. That I do not know; I cannot know that information. In consideration of the above, and using the general numbers currently for 2027, the 2027 payroll sits around $120M. Adding Jeffers brings back a bat that people like but it constrains the moves the team can further make. It also pushes back on a definitive goal that was slowly introduced last season, the need of improving the defense. Pushing back against that would seem counterproductive, at least to me. The pitchers need help from the guy they throw to. So it would take two things to bring back Ryan Jeffers. First, the team would have to backtrack on their movement towards fielding a better defensive team. Second, the Twins would be largely returning the same basic roster they currently employ because the budget is unlikely to go beyond $150M and even that seems like a bit of a stretch. I would rather the team make aggressive moves to add Jazz Chisholm on a 1 year high paying contract where he can rebuild his market value or sign the steady predictable Brandon Lowe. I would also hope the club can complete trades, hopefully 2-3. The beauty of it is that we just watch, guess like crazy, and then see what happens. The past practice has been largely disappointing. What will this November bring?
-
Matt Wallner: A Powerful Assessment
tony&rodney replied to Riverbrian's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
One could also just advocate for the return of Jose Miranda and Eddie Julien and hope they return to their best selves. Zoll and those who gather to make roster decisions must make their calls looking to 2027. The past is a memory. The best bat available for first base isn't a very good first baseman but he sure can still carry a team, Raffy Devers. If you insist on acquiring a big bat for first base, which is a worthy goal (not sure one that can be accomplished), Devers is your guy. What is your trade proposal? -
This is a really sound blueprint. There is much to like here. Lowe is a good add, Westburg is worth acquiring and even if it is odd for Baltimore to reacquire Kremer, I like that move. Miami might jump at that trade and the Twins need to move Royce if a sold bullpen arm returns. Campusano is sure to cost more but maybe Fermin works for both clubs. I believe Ober can be moved for something reasonable. I sent him to Arizona with Roden for Lawlar but Ober can return something. Good job. Only 20 people have participated in the blueprint and this is a good one.
-
Matt Wallner: A Powerful Assessment
tony&rodney replied to Riverbrian's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
This is probably the most accurate hope for Wallner if he hopes to play MLB ball again. The comparison to Ben Ross as a bat is interesting, but Ross does a pile of things Wallner cannot comprehend much less accomplish (run, field). Baseball is tough. A previous astute comment that reviewed how the Twins dugout staff took the roster, played it, and then made adjustments are a major reason Wallner is no longer an option as a Twin. He can hit an occasional home run off of the most mediocre of pitchers or horrible mistake pitches but otherwise is a total negative. Playing baseball at the highest level is incredibly hard and the best athletes struggle to make it. The rate of failure must be crushing to deal with on a daily basis. I feel for Wallner but he is done. As someone else suggested, there may be a place for him in Asia. Japan, Korea, Taiwan, and China are all amazing places if one is willing to roll into the culture. The baseball is really pretty good as well. A number of players have found their groove as baseball players and happiness playing in Asia. -
In general there seems to be both a fairly wide disinterest (based on a limited number of roster blueprints submitted) in this offseason and skeptical belief in the Twins ownership and front office. Seems warranted. Fans, though, have to make attempts to look beyond the unpleasant realities to some distant hope, although that vision should contain a minimum does of logic and possibility. We hear about the uselessness of many players on the roster and impossibility of completing trades from many on this site, but I would offer that there are opportunities. None of us can know what these are. We are just goofing around and submitting junk. I try to use ideas that may be possible but all ideas should get put down. Here is an example of a trade that will not happen but might actually benefit both teams possibly. The Twins send a pile of guys (Matthews, Caratini, Tait, Lee, Clemens, and milb pitcher LaPour) to the Reds for Ke'Bryan Hayes and Elly De La Cruz. The Twins give up 50 home runs from two regulars who are under control, a starting pitcher under control, a reserve catcher, and two prospects. The Reds rid themsleves of a contract they do not want. The loss of a superstar (Elly) is the stopper. The Twins fans will scream that Elly only has 3 years of control. It is easy for me and anyone else to condemn any idea but it is ideas that flow into actual trades. i did not criticize the Mahle trade although I hated it because the Twins were gambling on a positive move. I didn't like the idea of trading Polanco for nothing before it happened. We all know that wound up being a nothingburger. Hope is what we need and while it seems hard to go with plans that are not inspirational, we can hope.
-
Matt Wallner: A Powerful Assessment
tony&rodney replied to Riverbrian's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
After being sent to St. Paul, Matt Wallner made zero adjustments that would make him a better baseball player. He was difficult to watch when he played for the Saints. The only chance Wallner receives another MLB look is if he embarks on a full scale rebuild of his approach to baseball this winter and is miraculously changed come Spring Training. -
Command and control are as old as baseball itself. Good pitchers keep batters off balance and the best rack up strikeouts, sometimes on mediocre fastballs right down the middle of the plate. In all cases, except those few guys like Mason Miller, good defense is essential for pitchers. There is significant money to be made writing blogs and running sports sites, which makes the pursuit of analytics profitable. All analytics are attempts to capture what the most astute of baseball minds hold. They are useful in many ways but have holes, some more than others. Many are all in on analytics to the point of making specific judgments on players they have never seen play. There will always be variables and the irrational. People who love numbers and analytics could learn a lot by watching the games.
- 14 replies
-
- connor prielipp
- yoendrys gomez
- (and 8 more)
-
Thank you.
-
I hope Jeffers gets the money. Note that Willson Contreras last caught more than 50 games in 2023. Contreras is not a catcher, but then again Jeffers isn't likely much longer either. For those enamored with WAR, Jeffers has one season of 3 and 3 seasons above 2 WAR and only 4 seasons above 1. Contreras has 2 seasons above 4, 8 years above 3, and 11 where he reached 1 or higher WAR. I think the only comparison is that neither is much as a catcher. Otherwise it is a very slim comparison.
-
Just my thoughts (with zero idea of potential for completion) - trade Wallner and Sands to Pittsburgh for Henry Davis. Neither team gains or loses anything significant. This is a change of scenery move. Maybe Pitt wants Martin too. Larnach should have some value. While Houston wanted him in late July, they are uninterested now for next season unless he comes nearly free. Go to the SouthWest and perhaps Arizona sees that Larnach along with Roden gives them two LH bats (OF/DH/1B). Add Ober and ask for Jordan Lawlar in return to shore up the bottom of the Twins roster. Whatever, there should be opportunities.
- 19 replies
-
- carlos correa
- sonny gray
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
He was a few times, but the regular season does require more long term arm management. Newcomb and Ashby both were at 90 innings but Ashby appeared in more games. Of course, arm problems are always just around the corner and both Ashby and Newcomb have endured IL stints. Newcomb is a decent thought for the Twins. I like Rojas in a bullpen role as he learns the ropes at the highest levels of baseball. Morejon is going to get a huge pile of money. There was a guess of 5/$105M just recently. I would like to see the Twins offer Morejon 4/$82M with an opt out after two years.
- 23 replies
-
- kris bubic
- sean newcomb
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
Jeffers, and finding bullpen help along with one bat, is part of a litmus test for the Twins. We won't know whether Jeffers rejects or accepts the QO for two weeks unless he comes out with a decision before the deadline. An early decision helps because adding $23M to the roster numbers will change some possible moves. Hopefully Jeffers can make his decision this week. Zoll (the entire front office) together with Tom Pohlad (if he needs to be in on everything) can get to work right now, particularly on smaller actions. There are opportunities to address the roster through transactions and trades. There is no reason to wait.

