Kyle can hit. We all saw it... He can hit.
Unfortunately he was never allowed to hit against right handers.
This has reduced his value to nearly nothing as a short side platoon guy.
This roster can't afford to retain a short side platoon guy.
The OF currently consists of:
One Superstar (Buxton) who struggles to stay healthy.
Two vets (Gallo and Kepler) that we HOPE rebound from two year slumps.
One guy (Gordon) with a one decent year under his belt.
Four young players (Kirilloff, Larnach, Wallner, Celestino) who haven't yet accomplished as much as Nick Gordon has at the MLB Level.
We need Kirilloff, Larnach and Gordon to compete with Gallo and Kepler in case Gallo and Kepler turn into 3 year slumps.
All of the outfield 26 man roster spots need to belong to players who are contenders for playing time to compete against each other to find a player who helps us win.
Garlick will never be allowed to be a contender for playing time because he has been made a specialist and hardened in that role over the course of 4 years.
It isn't his fault that he was turned into a specialist but he has been so therefore... very little value to us and others.
He is the obvious choice.