If you watch the second replay of the broadcast after the catch, you can see the ball most of the time. It's going to right center off the bat and then knuckles back to center. Buxton's reactions are perfectly in line with what the ball is doing. Besides, if there's one thing we can't really question about Buxton, it's his flyball reaction speed and route. He's elite in that regard. He doesn't just take "bad routes", as his read off the bat is pretty stellar. This was just a weird ball and he managed to catch it. Again, I wish Buxton would lay up more often but the way he played this ball was masterful. https://www.mlb.com/gameday/tigers-vs-twins/2019/04/14/566967#game_state=final,lock_state=final,game_tab=videos,game=566967