Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Brent Headrick The Starter?


    Cody Pirkl

    Brent Headrick has been a pleasant surprise to begin the season, to say the least. Currently stuck in an up-and-down long relief role, could he be a starting option with the recent injuries?

    Image courtesy of William Parmeter

    Twins Video

    Brent Headrick wasn’t one of the Twins locks to be added to the 40-man roster this winter but made the cut along with Casey Legumina who was later traded to Cincinnati. Despite being somewhat of an afterthought, the left-hander has been one of the more impressive up-and-down pitchers on the roster this season. The Twins could possibly start looking for a way to get him up for good soon.

    Headrick’s MLB career is in its infancy having only made three appearances to date. We can be cautious given the incredibly small sample size, but the early results are encouraging. In 8 1/3 innings, Headrick has a 3.24 ERA and 12 strikeouts. His WHIP stands at an impressive 0.96. He’s showing signs of being able to consistently retire Major League hitters, and it can be argued that may be going to waste in a long relief role. 

    Headrick is in an interesting spot. The Twins clearly believed in him having protected him from the Rule 5 draft. It’s important to note that his addition to the 40-man has to speed up his timeline to the big leagues which is likely why he’s filling long relief innings. So far, his effectiveness in bulk innings makes it worth wondering whether Headrick could be a usable big-league starting pitcher.

    The dominoes are starting to fall at the big-league level. Kenta Maeda's injury has opened up a well-deserved opportunity for Bailey Ober, who very well may not allow Maeda to get his job back when healthy. On Thursday night, Tyler Mahle left his start after four innings due to elbow soreness. He played down the injury after the game, but at this point, it's a little difficult to take Mahle's word after several brief returns from the IL only to head right back in 2022. We hope it's just an early-season tweak, but the Twins should be making plans in case it isn't.

    The likely replacement for Mahle is Louie Varland, who appears to be another MLB-worthy starter stuck in Triple-A due to the roster crunch. The Twins pitching depth is coming through for them early, but it's already beginning to run out.

    Assuming Ober and Varland get the call, the Twins' rotation in Triple-A will be headed by Simeon Woods Richardson. The right-hander the Twins got in the Jose Berrios trade has already debuted this season in long relief. It's possible he would be the next man up, but his future as a starting pitcher is not yet written in stone. He appears to have a fastball that's going to regularly dip into the 80s with a changeup as his main secondary pitch.

    Even if the Twins' plan is for Woods Richardson to be slotted into the rotation in the event of another injury, he's the tail end of the list of starters you want to see called up. Aaron Sanchez, Jose De Leon, and Dereck Rodriguez are the best of what's left. Given what we've seen from Headrick, it may be time to settle him into a role as a legitimate starting pitcher.

    Headrick has only made nine starts above A-Ball but has essentially reached a starter's workload in the MLB. Dropping him into the Triple-A rotation should be an easy task and should leave him available if the Twins still need to cycle him in occasionally as a long reliever. His success thus far at the MLB level (and his spot on the 40-man roster) has put him ahead of the veteran minor-league signings they have stashed away in Triple-A. Veteran starting pitching depth is great to have, but it's hard to call it depth when there's so little promise in the event that any of these guys get called up.

    Headrick has been found money for the Twins, and he could wind up playing a bigger role than many thought he would when he was given a 40-man roster spot in the offseason. He may not be the most seasoned starting pitching prospect, but what he's shown in the majors should be taken into account. The Twins should have Brent Headrick starting every fifth day in Triple-A. To have another seemingly solid starter waiting in the wings could pay off, especially on with the health luck the Twins have had in recent years. Do you agree?

    MORE FROM TWINS DAILY
    — Latest Twins coverage from our writers
    — Recent Twins discussion in our forums
    — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email
    — Become a Twins Daily Caretaker

     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    He does throw strikes but it is a SSS as a reliever here at MLB  level  ...

    Would be fine to keep him stretched out as a starter or a long relief guy ...

    I'm sure he would be grateful  for whatever opportunities the twins would have for him  ...

    Give him playing time at the MLB level for a complete analysis , not sure what he is in the long term  but time will tell  ...

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    IMO any time in the MLB is not wasted. The 5 innings he pitched earlier is invaluable. Headrick is 4th man on the totem pole behind Ober, Varland & SWR and any innings he gets in the MLB level would be much more valuable than in AAA. IMO will be a SP but that does mean he can't get some time in at long relief on the MLB level

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I'm confused about Brett Headrick. He appears to be a standard big, strong, young lefty with standard stuff, a few good pitches, nothing amazing, but good command of all of it. He gets guys out without epic battles. Doesn't appear overwhelmed by the situation, doesn't look like he's exerting max effort with each pitch. 

    If Mahle needs to be replaced, I would have a hard time favoring Louie Varland over Headrick. Varland's heater has a few more ticks, but Headrick doesn't strain as much to get guys out. Either one looks like a good mid-rotation starter. How is Headrick deficient?

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    It will be interesting to see who the Twins use in Mahle's spot. It seems like Varland would have the edge over Headrick or Woods Richardson, but we may even see a bullpen game depending on what management thinks. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Maeda could be out most of May. Same story or worse for Mahle.

    That said, we should have a long-term plan and not just who’s going to start next couple starts.

    My rotation starting tomorrow:

    Ryan - Varland - López - Ober - Gray

    Pen stable by May 15:

    Headrick - Winder - Stewart - Maeda - Duran - Jax - Thielbar - López……….Balazavic & Alcala in wings

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I ws a little amazed when they did send Headrick down after his five inning stint. He could've just slipped in the Madea spot to start (or a spot the Twins could momentarily delay due to an off Monday).

    A left-handed starter is something the Twins do lack, even if you can get a solid five innings (remember, we had Smeltzer last year).

    Maybe it is because he is the new guy on the block, and the Twins have more faith in Winder, although optioning Winder for a bit more play at St. Paul is what I would've done. Or sent off Moran to work moorore on his stuff. Moran, like Headrick, shows soo much promise as being a lefty arm that can easily pitch 2-3 innings, go thru a batting order, which is what you love in the bullpen.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    21 hours ago, jimbo92107 said:

    I'm confused about Brett Headrick. He appears to be a standard big, strong, young lefty with standard stuff, a few good pitches, nothing amazing, but good command of all of it. He gets guys out without epic battles. Doesn't appear overwhelmed by the situation, doesn't look like he's exerting max effort with each pitch. 

    If Mahle needs to be replaced, I would have a hard time favoring Louie Varland over Headrick. Varland's heater has a few more ticks, but Headrick doesn't strain as much to get guys out. Either one looks like a good mid-rotation starter. How is Headrick deficient?

    Varland has been the 2x Minor League Pitcher of the Year for the Twins, his stuff numbers look significantly better, and he's had a traditional path through the minors as a starter whereas Headrick has only made 9 starts above A ball. That doesn't mean Varland will necessarily be better, but he's also been solid across 4 starts in the majors. My guess is the Twins give Varland the first chance.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    17 hours ago, JD-TWINS said:

    Maeda could be out most of May. Same story or worse for Mahle.

    That said, we should have a long-term plan and not just who’s going to start next couple starts.

    My rotation starting tomorrow:

    Ryan - Varland - López - Ober - Gray

    Pen stable by May 15:

    Headrick - Winder - Stewart - Maeda - Duran - Jax - Thielbar - López……….Balazavic & Alcala in wings

    Now that Mahle is definitely out through most of June, at a minimum, Headrick will be in the staff & not bouncing up & down. Still a long man though, as that is our need, stable long man!!

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I've been very impressed with Headrick so far. Stuff is solid, as is the control. Now, is his future in the rotation or the pen? No clue at this point.  And while I don't want to be glib and just say "anyone can pitch in relief", it sure is easier to transition to the pen then back to the rotation.

    He should be starting every 5th day for St Paul and brought up as necessary, whether to start or toss out of the pen. 

    In an ideal world, the new and improved Stewart is for real. And he...haven't given up on Alcala or Winder yet...would combine with someone like Headrick to give the Twins a pair of excellent 1-2IP middle guys to make the pen 7 deep. You can still leave the 8th spot open for a revolving long man to be swapped out as necessary. That 8th spot is also a great way for young arms to get their feet wet.

    But for now, Headrick staying stretched out makes the most sense to me. I mean, Sands and Winder are moving to the pen. I still think Balazovic is going back to starting and is only the pen for the time being. But rotation depth is getting a little short on the farm right now.

     

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    9 hours ago, DocBauer said:

    That 8th spot is also a great way for young arms to get their feet wet.

    This gets my early vote for best mixed metaphor of the year!

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Starter or bullpen? That is the question for not only Headrick, but also Josh Winder and Cole Sands. It appears the decision has been made on both Winder and Sands and they will be bullpen options for the Twins. Headrick is not as clear a decision.

    As was mentioned above, the Twins lack left handed starters (and relievers for that matter) so I think there should be enhanced consideration for Headrick to eventually be a starter for the major league team. It was noted also that Headrick only has nine starts above A ball, what wasn't noted is that he has been a starter, with only five minor league relief appearances since he began his career in 2019. 

    It remains to be seen if Headrick is above former major leaguers Dobnak, Sanchez, and DeLeon (none of them on the 40-man roster) as well as Woods Richardson. With Mahle out for at least the month of May and Maeda out at least a couple weeks, it is probable that someone currently in the St. Paul rotation will be starting games for the Twins sometime this year.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    On 4/30/2023 at 10:20 AM, Doctor Gast said:

    IMO any time in the MLB is not wasted. The 5 innings he pitched earlier is invaluable. Headrick is 4th man on the totem pole behind Ober, Varland & SWR and any innings he gets in the MLB level would be much more valuable than in AAA. IMO will be a SP but that does mean he can't get some time in at long relief on the MLB level

    Plus he's left handed which I would love to have in the rotation to break the all righty rotation  we have ...

    Pitching a lefthander in rotation would have the other teams having to make adjustments in there batting order  ...

    Hope he can succeed  ...

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...