Agreed. Those who claim "BUT HIS DEFENSE" are assuming that Buxton is somehow saving 1-2 runs per game. This is a fantasy. We want to believe it, because we are Buxton fans and Twins fans. But that doesn't make it so. Buxton is not a hockey goalie. That said, what's impressed me the most this year is that his bat has come around. I'm totally fine with him batting .264, among the league leaders in doubles and steals. If you combine those stats with his above average defense, you've got yourself a nice starting outfielder. And at this point, that's all we should hope for with Buxton. Polanco is younger than Buxton and has accomplished far more than Buxton has if you compare their careers. It's time to admit that Buxton will probably never live up to the hype, and we should be happy if we can get a few injury-free years of solid ball from him. Just like many here, he's probably my favorite player to root for. But we have to start adjusting our expectations, and face the reality that he might not be that special after all.