No, I agree, you get a lemon once in awhile, but the track record of finding a closer, especially in the Twins case, is much better than finding players at any other position. Except for the rare hiccup (Matt Capps, Trombley) the Twins have had pretty reliable chain of closers since Davis, nearly 30 years ago. Reardon-Aguilera-Guardado-Nathan-Perkins, with 11 All-Star games amongst them. Likely, if other guys had been installed as closer, they would have finished with a similar number of saves. The only reason Davis is so widely remembered as a bust, was because they incredibally did not pull the plug on him. And it's teams who have the Ron Davis' that hopefully will be willing to trade for a new closer instead of looking internally.