For me, I'm most concerned about this year. Is he playing better THIS year? How many bad routes, misplays has he had THIS year? We all know how bad he was the past two years. Is this ONE play an indicator that he hasn't turned any corner or improved from previous years? Does this one play, misplay or not, prove that? It seems debatable it was a misplay … some say yes, some say no … so, we are not all in agreement on that. Perhaps both sides of this can give a little bit of a benefit of the doubt and agree to disagree or at least admit the other may have a point to consider. But are you saying that you think Hicks is the same Hicks as last year based on this? Or are there other plays this year that maybe, just maybe, prove otherwise? I will wait until we are further into the season to make any such suppositions, and it's okay that you are certain now. But others aren't … so let's just back away and stop bristling at one another. Edit: despite quoting Levi in the post, I was making a general statement to all … not just him.