Perhaps if you didn't continue to post the brawls to revel in them, even hope for them to occur, others who don't like them wouldn't post opinions to the contrary. That said, I really don't mind that you post these articles because it IS baseball news, and I do appreciate the articles you post on baseball in the other forums as well as here. However, I'm not sure what you expect people to do ... not post their opinions of an article in a public forum? I think there is a pretty even split in how posters here feel about these brawls and how they start; and whenever they get started by a pitcher who intentionally throws at a batter, and not even in the heat of the moment as was pointed out in subsequent articles that Strickland was 'out to get' Harper, I can guarantee this is how the thread is likely to go. I don't think that's silly. I also don't think potential serious, life-threatening or career-ending injury is silly, especially done with the intent Strickland showed. I don't think adult men playing a game resorting to violence is silly. Do I get why it happens? Yes, to some extent. Doesn't mean I think it should and will always hope there is a way to evolve without destroying the passion of the game.