The really stupid thing about this unwritten rule: Yeah, so Haley plunked their CF. Didn't see the pitch, but from reading others on here, it was an accident. Because Haley doesn't get to hit, the Tigers get to CHOOSE who they want to plunk on the Twins. So they choose the team's best player. If the whole point of the rule is to retaliate and things are over, how is that fair that the Tigers get to decide when and whom is getting plunked?