All of this is fair. I agree with Clay's points that: - Republicans should be fighting identity politics with ideas, not their own version of identity politics. It's valid to challenge the ideas of the 4 congresswomen he called out. But his communication is so piss poor, especially on Twitter, that caused the outrage. - We should be thankful to be born and living in the US. For all of the country's faults and past history, this is still a great place to build a life.