I wouldn’t say my track record is great for evaluating QBs, but I really don’t see what there is to like about McCarthy to elevate him to top 10 status. He looked like nothing more than a game manager in the games I watched this year. I watched all of their games at the end of the season thinking okay, maybe now they’ll rely on him more for the Big 10 championship game and the playoffs. Nope, he continued to hand the ball off 40+ times and throw maybe 20 passes a game.