The Jays package was way superior to that Twins one. Reyes is far more valuable than Santana, and Hoffman has better numbers in the same league as Stewart despite coming off Tommy John. Miguel Castro struck out a batter/inning at 3 levels of A ball as a 19 year old last year while throwing up a 2.68 ERA and a .178 BAA. He's been worse this year, mostly because the Jays jumped him up too far too fast. Meanwhile, Meyer this year at 25 has a 5.97 ERA in AAA, so Castro is better than Meyer. So what it comes down to is Tinoco v Arcia. Tinoco turned 20 in April, and has been starting all year at low A, where he's put up a 3.30 ERA, 7.7 k/9, 2.3 bb/9, and a .266 BAA. Arcia turned 24 in May, and has only OPS'd .695 at AAA (despite his past power-hitting success), while striking out 29% of the time, and putting up a 4.1/1 k/bb ratio. Add to the fact that the Rockies can't DH him, and he becomes even less valuable. I think it's pretty clear to anyone that isn't over-valuing Santana/Stewart/Meyer/Arcia that the Jays package is better.