Because there is a point to which this is detrimental. I can give you example after example of guys who were called up too early and never panned out. In recent memory, Carlos Gomez and Delmon Young. In Young's case, the contract kind of forced it, and in Gomez case, they had to have something to show for the Santana trade, and look what happened... Gomez never amounted to anything close to his potential, and Young just started getting tolerable when he got expensive, at which point he regressed again. Both had star potential in the big leagues and neither will ever amount to much of anything. I agree that there are other issues here, but Lev's point is very valid. You have to do what is best for both the org an the player. My big thing is that Dozier (and Parmalee for that matter) should be playing every day. I'm presently not terribly worried where either is playing, though the case for Dozier is looking more and more like AAA. He's making mistakes that he didn't make before.... that's a sign of not being ready... it isn't a knock on Dozier as much as a recognition that 2012 may not be his year, and spending time in Rochester might be in his best interest. As for the org, there is one other big thing... service time. I know we have money now, but that still doesn't mean make stupid decisions. If he needs developmental time, there's no reason why he cannot develop in AAA where his clock isn't ticking. It certainly shouldn't be the sole reason for doing this as it was in the past, but if he's clearly not ready, then don't waste the time.