I don't think the final decision will be all that tough. This is just a bunch of silly hand-wringing over, at best, middle of the road pitchers. I start with "Buy low/sell high". If you want something that get somewhat of a decent return, you trade Pelfrey. Yes, you're taking a chance that Pelfrey could really be what we're seeing now. So what? That's the nature of the beast. Gibson also falls into this category. Soft-tossing lefties have something of a successful track record in the fastball-dominate NL. Trade Milone. Gibson also, to a lessor extent, falls into this category. Hughes and May. I warned about the possible fall of Hughes: in season by season stats, Hughes would have one good year [with career high number of innings pitched] only to fall miserably the next year. 2015 = The next year. How could anyone think 16 BB's for the entire season would be sustainable? Every team knows that Hughes WILL put the ball over the plate, the biggest reason I was against the extension. May has been doing well, but very much an 'up and down' guy. I have to reason not to trade either, if trading Hughes s even possible. It still comes down to one thing: What do other teams think of them??