I actually thought it was okay, even good, to use Colome at that point. We talk about it being audition time when you’re down a bazillion games, but that goes for veterans as well. Colome was horrible at the beginning of the year, as we all know, but had brought his ERA down by more than a run and eventually by 1.7 runs. In his last 26.2 innings, he had a 3.38 ERA and only gave up two homers.
Most importantly, he had an option that would have been relatively inexpensive. I think it was wise to run him out there as a closer to see if he had turned things around enough to pick up the option. Apparently they decided not to.
I don’t remember how Alcala was doing, but it doesn’t seem like they ever saw him as a closer. Using Colome in the ninth allowed them to further audition Alcala as a set-up guy.
But that’s my take, and I’m not in the front office.