While i understand the WAR justification for an extension and he has been fairly solid at 2nd defensively, why do we lock him up through arbitration years? He’s not a super star in the making batting in the low .240's and his salary through arbitration won’t be significantly higher than signing him to an extension now. Furthermore, locking him up through arbitration provides little value in a trade situation as he’s still under team control for the same period. 2014 Before and After All Star Break .242/.340/.436 – OPS .776, 12.3% BB Rate, 18.6% K Rate, .194 ISO (Driver of OPS = highly unsustainable HR Rate + unsustainable BB rate) .244/.352/.387 – OPS .739, 13.1% BB Rate, 17.7% K Rate, .143 ISO Fans tend to forget that Dozier has been very inconsistent at the plate throughout his career. His approach and batting style have changed over and over again as he's searched for the right formula to be a legitimate MLB hitter. This is illustrated by the erratic batting averages as he rose from GCL in 2009 to ROC 2011/2012. Dozier’s power is borderline and his ISO is driven by his extreme tendency to pull the ball (something players tend to do at the end of their careers), but that’s also why his average is awful. From 2011 in AA New Britain through 2013, he sat at a maximum BB rate of 8.2% before jumping to 12.6% last year, and it’s not like he showed the eye in 2013 or even in the 2nd half of 2013 (the first glimpse he might belong in MLB). The fact of the matter is that Dozier has just as much track record as a AAAA player as he does a MLB starter. And while his 2014 OPS of .762 and OBP of .345 is absolutely intoxicating to some fans, it's probably a CAREER year that he will never come close to duplicating again. If he continues to pull the ball like he does, opposing teams will catch onto him, similar to what happened to Lew Ford. He’s not the kind of player the Twins need to be in a rush to lock up right now. Let him play another year before making a decision.