I never used the phrase utterly failed. I'm happy to have conversations if people want....but let's not exaggerate positions to make points. I think it will be hard to find trades like Odo, because when you look at trades for good SPs, you don't see many like it. As for Perez, if Wes Johnson can do this every year, he should be paid about 100MM per year. Again, it just doesn't happen all that often that a guy is so bad he's cut by a team desperate for pitching, has an ERA in the high 5s, and then becomes a good pitcher the next year. I don't see either as consistently repeatable because it doesn't happen across the league every year, let alone for one team every year.