Buxton is the same as Taylor?
Taylor's 2024 WAR is .1
Buxton's 2024 WAR is 1.6
(Fangraphs WAR, that is)
WAR accounts for playing time, defense, strikeouts, etc. It's not perfect, but it's the best comprehensive measure of contributions I know of. Taylor's basically a replacement level player. That's worthwhile. But Buxton's been much, much better this year.