Not sure if serious, but: - your numbers are incorrect (looking at wrong column? Clippard has 53 saves, and only 38 blown saves) - total games pitched obviously doesn't indicate opportunities for blown saves (some pitchers are brought in tied or trailing more often, or leading by more than 3 runs, in which case it is impossible to blow a save) -- fortunately B-Ref keeps track of "SVSit" which is any save situation the pitcher enters - setup man numbers should include holds (where a lead was preserved in a save situation, even if they pitcher didn't finish the game to get the save) http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/j/jepseke01-pitch.shtml#pitching_reliever::none http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/c/clippty01-pitch.shtml#pitching_reliever::none Using those numbers, we see that both pitchers have roughly the same percentage of (holds + saves) divided by save situations. Jepsen is about 4% higher, but he's also about 11% lower in rate of opportunity (save situations divided by total relief games), so it's basically a wash. By WAR, which factors in leverage and opportunity, Clippard has 6 of his last 7 seasons at 1.2 WAR or greater -- really a pretty incredible run of quality setup pitching. Jepsen has met that mark (or even come close) only twice in his career. I don't think there is a great Clippard over Jepsen argument, but there is a fantastic Clippard (or other affordable reliever) PLUS Jepsen argument, which would reduce our reliance on Jepsen.