It was you who said he was arguably the best defensive shortstop in the majors this year and now in this post you say he isn't. So why are you so bothered I was definitive in my statement that he isn't? He's 8th in RZR (actual range), he's 20th in plays made OOZ, he's 5th in UZR and he's 11th in defensive runs saved. And, not only that, you watch some of the other guys play the position, like Tulo, Simmons and Andrus, yeah I think it's a stretch to suggest he's the best defensive SS in baseball. I know it's the in thing to say that everything is opinion, but not everything is opinion. I don't see any argument that can be made for Florimon to be considered the best defensive shortstop. You haven't made one that's convincing. In my opinion, an argument could be made for Tulo and Simmons along with Andrus. If I'm just going off what I've seen this year, it's Simmons and Tulo neck and neck. As long as Brendan Ryan is healthy, he may very well he there in the discusssion at the end of the year too.