If you think the A's believed the downgrade would be this severe, you're fooling yourself. He overplayed his hand here (and throughout the last offseason) and has largely set his team back with the moves he's made. He gave up more for than what he got out of Samardzjia, this deal looks like a huge loser, the Butler signing looks as dumb as was expected, and part of why they're in this boat (if you want to say bad luck) is largely due to his own design. (See, the infield defense and bullpen) Be a Beane fan all you want, but this last calendar year hasn't been good and his team's record shows it.