If your 7th inning guy comes in and turns a 2-1 game into 6-1 do you just leave him in to finish the game then too? I guess I just have never seen a baseball team, in any era of the game, leave guys out to get shellacked in order to spare the rest of the bullpen. (Well, beyond the mop-up guy I guess. But even then we put in position players often) The psychological impact of ballooning your ERA and the reaction of fans are just two of many reasons why it's never been common practice IMO. I know you weren't necessarily throwing Molitor under the bus for these decisions, but it is coming up. I'm not sure what people want Molitor to do. I guess he could offer to forfeit, but with the way his staff is pitching we might blame him for waiting until the 5th. Some nights he might as well do it pre-game.